Talk:Derek Hale/@comment-Maria Trimble-20120815202905/@comment-Maria Trimble-20120816214444

I think you are repeatedly missing my point with the "out of control" comment. I'm saying that, full moon or not, they were still out of control and he had to take care of them. And if they had "no control" of themselves, why did Isaac come back and help? Why didn't Scott change at all for the moon? We don't know for sure that he didn't tell them everything. We can only go by what we've seen on screen, remember? And how was he supposed to know when he turned them that Gerard was a geriatric nut job, or that Allison was going to go crazy and kill them, or that there was a freaking lizard creature running around murdering people? None of that was happening when he turned them. So of course he couldn't tell them that any of this was going to happen. He told them all of the problems they were facing AT THE MOMENT would go away (Erica's epilepsy, Boyd's weight, etc.) and they did. But like I said, he didn't know any of the things that happened were going to happen. And I've already said that if Erica didn't, Isaac still did. So what you said about none of them giving lip is still untrue...