User blog:Stuartfergie/Changing the current policy of deleting and editing comments

Hello,

Myself and from what I gather from comments I have seen in this wiki, the current deletion and editing of comments by the sole admin Paul.rea is in debate. I, myself think Paul does a wonderful job with the wiki. However, this one aspect of comments seems drastic and uncommunity like.

Currently, he is deleting any comments that contain what he deems as incorrect information. However, this includes what people think may or may not happen, such as theories using current cannon. I understand that this is unacceptable in the articles, however, the comments section is for the opinion of the community, of which is there opinion on what may happen. They do not claim to be facts and it clearly states on the wiki that speculation based on the facts of the show are allowed. Therefore this should extend to any theories about the show.

Although Paul has my respect in the aspect of running the articles, I feel that the way he runs the comment section is very anti-community as well as locking the pages down for edit, making himself the sole admin of this wiki and dismissing any objections of the community to deletions. He also appears to ban users without warning.

Im not saying he is unfit to be an admin. But the wiki should be more community based as it was intended. It is my opinion that he should allow theories in the comment section, add additional admins and issue warnings before banning.

The wiki should be run like the community driven wiki it is suppose to be and not one mans website. Please comment and add opinions on if you agree with my points or not and why?

I understand if the community disagrees with me, but I just want the community to be able to have its say without any edits or deletions.

All the best,

Stuartfergie (talk) 15:41, July 5, 2013 (UTC)