Board Thread:False Info and Speculative Discussion/@comment-24732895-20160411234226/@comment-5237598-20160512144452

Honestlycynical wrote: ^ Just wanna point out two things.

1) Scott was referring to his eyes turning blue from killing Jennifer. We don't know if they would actually turn blue since she's far from innocent. However, as the show doesn't define what an "innocent life" is, his assumption that his eyes (should he hypothetically lose his Alpha spark) would turn blue is... questionable due to no canon definition of what constitutes an innocent life. She straight up murdered like... 13 people, maybe? Generally that wouldn't be classified as "innocent" in any sense of the word. ANYWAY, it certainly doesn't suggest that the no killing rule applies, though. All it really suggests is that Scott has the idea that if he were to kill Jennifer, his eyes would become that "cold blue" that comes with taking an innocent life. On this point, it's better to just leave it as an "agree to disagree" thing and carry on. I disagree. Why would he talk about blues eyes? It doesn't make any sense to me. At that Point, he knew he was an Alpha. He even said so himself. I don't remember the exact dialogue between Scott and Jennifer but it went something like this: Scott breaks the mountain ash barrier. Jennifer asks how he did it. He answers: "I'm an Alpha now". And then he goes on about killing her should he repeat her Actions no matter what it does to the Color of his eyes... Now since he is an Alpha, the blue Color is irrelevant for two reasons. Should he kill her, even as a Beta, I highly doubt that his eye Color would swith to blue... I think we can all agree that Jennifer was not an innocent Person. Should he not lose his powers by killing her then, innocent or not, his eyes would stay red. This is why I think when he was talking about his eyes, he was actually talking about his Alpha Status which he might lose... IDK if what I just said made sense to anyone but me, haha. I did my best.