Board Thread:False Info and Speculative Discussion/@comment-24.130.28.230-20150721180826/@comment-27547895-20160130202947

Paul.rea wrote: Had they not been so unequivocal in saying "nothing supernatural can cross" then you would be right. In this case, they gave us a clear landmark in judging the supernatural. Can cross mountain ash, not supernatural. Can't cross mountain, supernatural.

All Banshee seen on the show are able to use and cross mountain ash meaning, by the definition of the show, banshee are not supernatural.

They could have said "shapeshifters can't cross." They could have said "Werewolves and Kanima can't cross." They didn't. They said "nothing supernatural." Which, again, is more evidence of poor writing and a lack of continuity than anything. Even if you DO want to use it as evidence that Lydia, or banshees in general, are not supernatural... that's all it is...evidence. Evidence easily countered by easily over a dozen supernatural feats Lydia and other banshees have performed. The show has not explicitly said that banshees are not supernatural. Therefore, again, your theory is nothing more than headcanon. It will remain headcanon until such time as Jeff Davis explains it.

You're supposedly a smart guy, so I'm sure you can see that.

Cheers.