Board Thread:WARNING ALL USERS False Info\Spoilers/@comment-16138660-20130822010603/@comment-9953709-20130824060959

Pizzanigs wrote: PrimeEra wrote: Pizzanigs wrote: PrimeEra wrote: Karina7206 wrote: Whoever keeps saying Derek and Laura were in the fire is wrong. Derek and Laura were BOTH at school when the fire happened. 11 members NOT including Derek and Laura were in the fire. 8 died. That means there are 3 left. Cora and Peter were 2/3 Hales still alive. There is one unnamed Hale still alive. No one is saying laura and derek were in the fire, im stating 8 total people died which was reported, a 11 people who lived in the house/family memebers 8+3=Derek,peter,laura those 3 survived derek and laura were at school when it happen and peter managed to survive. Cora was never mention or introduced tell season 3. thats why Wtf? How are they survivors if they weren't even involved in the fire? That's like saying I'm a survivor of the earthquakes in Japan. You dont grasp that they managed to survive beccause they were at school when it happen. That doesn't make them survivors of that fire because they were not IN that fire. If you are a survivor of a plane crash, it was because you were IN that plane crash and you managed to survive. I'm not going to call myself a survivor of a plane crash because I "survived" because I was at home and not on the plane.

i did not say they are suvivors, i just said they managed to survive the fire instead of those in their family that perished.