Board Thread:False Info and Speculative Discussion/@comment-6529205-20140419164329/@comment-81.97.84.26-20140723143328

i think that Stalia is doomed from the start and really if we're being honest shouldn't have started at all

lets just break it down a bit:

Malia has lived most of her life as wild and feral coyote so any relationship that would start between then would be bound by those animalistic instincts she developed and let take control which would now be so depely ingrained into her personality that the short amount of time shes been in human form again cant have possibly gotten rid of it. This would mean for sure that if they got into a proper relatoinship it would be very abusive on Malia's part because she wouldn't understand anything about whats going on or social things and would unwitingly revert back to the "take what i want/need by force" mindset she would have had to have had to survive as a coyote

She should be mentally about 8 years old. There is no way that as a feral coyote she would have been able to develop a human teenagers mentality. I'll concede that she may have been able to develop a little and might have good reasoning or problem solving skills but there is no way she could be a functional person and she all this'll be for her is a childhood crush if that becuase, honestly, it seems to me to be a bit of hero worship in that he helped get her out of that and at Eichen House they sort of became friends in a way and shes been copying him like with the highlighters and said she would ditch everyone but him. Now thats not love or anything like it if it was she would try to be her person with him and care about his friends too, and anyway if they did get into a relationship it would be really bad of Stiles simply because he would be taking advantage of Malia and her infantile understanding of things I mean she cant even get arguably simple maths so how is she meant to get what all of this relationship stuff actually means.

It's all happening too fast. They've not known each other that long and don't really know that much about each other. Literally the second time they met and the first time they properly met they made out in the basement of Eichen House and that isn't he proper basis of a relationship really the only time I can seriously consider two teenagers making out the first time they meet each other in a basement is in a game of spin the bottle at a party or something cheesey like that. This is seems to be going to a fast in fast out relationship that'll be very  unstable and possibly very bad for both of them but more so for Stiles, I woudl expect.

Really this all just screams bad idea and sloppy writing. It destroys so much character development and build up through the series and I frimly believe that if Jeff thinks what he's doing is right and the best thing for the show then he is so sorely mistaken that I would question his sanity and position on the shows team.

Unless Jeff has something really clever or a big plot twist up his sleeve then I think this is going to be one of worse sub-plots on the show. That being said I do have my faith that he'll be able to pull it out of the bag so long as that involves what ever is going on with their relationship to stop and be cut off.

All this being said though I don't dislike Malia, I think her character is an interesting addition to the show and it's dynamics, but I completely hate Stalia and not because I would rather have Stydia or that I ship Sterek it's just simply because it's a stupid idea and cheap plot