Board Thread:WARNING ALL USERS False Info\Spoilers/@comment-209.141.131.212-20130709011039/@comment-11533671-20130805000731

Ok I'll be brief this time, at least I'll try. My theory is based on facts that are in relation to other facts. I already gave them but here is an example since you are asking for one:

Fact 1) Kate Argent lived and died within 1983-2011; 2) The Hale fire that Kate started took place 6 years before the start of the show in 2011; 3) Based on 1 and 2 we can see that Kate has to be 18 in 2004. All of these facts are in relation to one another. You are expecting me to PROVE Dereks age? I can't do that. I CAN come to a close approximation and have already done that based on what the show has said and based on what the writers have said.

Wow, you found pics of people that wear the fashion. Ok...let me retort.

Beacon Hills is a small town. At the local high school we see Derek, Paige and Dereks friends. Now, the black friend of Derek has a hair style and wears a button up collar shirt that is immediately recognized by MOST people as fashion choices from the late 80s/early 90s. Maybe he just likes that style you say. OK....OMG! Derek also loves that era to! He likes the plaid shirt and hair cut of the same time period! Nah, that is just coincidence right? OK....HOLY BATSTICKS BATMAN!!!! Paige! She ALSO has the same styling sense! So now we have 3 high school kids that share a love of fashion made definable by the same time period that also happen to wear the same style together on the same day! Still coincidence? I doubt it.

Look, I respect your opinion, I really do. I am also aware that the show could end up tearing up my theory in every possible way with future episodes. I am ok with that. I know that my theory is only a theory unless the show adapts it and proves it right. I'm not saying that I CAN'T be wrong. I am saying that based on the show so far, I am closer to being right then most. Based on the show so far, my theory isn't wrong even if it isn't all right. Maybe I am wrong. I accept that. What makes me wrong then? The show nor the writers have given us anything that says my theory is completely wrong. Only your opinion has refuted it. An opinion that isn't based on the show at all, but out of your grasping for small points to latch onto and dispute.

Finally, this started because you said that you don't come to the forums much any more because what I had posted didn't contain any facts and was just assumption based on nothing. I have now proven that my conclusions are based on the show. My assumptions and speculations have used facts from the show so support one another. All of this translates to a theory. A theory that certainly CAN be debated and probably CAN be wrong but it is still a viable one. Unless you are trying to discredit my theory because you KNOW that I am revealing things the writers don't want let out yet then the only possible purpose of your comment is to do as trolls on other sites tend to do....refuse any facts and debate/nitpick at small insignificant details in order to rile people up. Your dispute still hasn't answered my questions. Since you like nitpicking....I believe you still have yet to prove to me how Kate Argent could have been 40 and Derek in high school when they dated? She died at the age of 28 according to the show, so is her tombstone wrong? Did Jeff tell you that her date of birth was altered and fake to?