Board Thread:Legitimate Canon Questions/@comment-4083360-20140108131256/@comment-4091815-20140108204047

To clarify -

The answer to the more specific question of killing an innocent WHILE AN ALPHA is "We don't know."

The reason the answer is "We don't know" is because we've never seen an Alpha kill an innocent WHILE THEY WERE AN ALPHA.

People are confused by the fact that both Peter and Derek have blue eyes suggesting they both killed innocents.

We never saw Peter kill an innocent WHILE he was the Alpha - none of his victims in Season 1 were innocent since they were all involved in some fashion in the Hale Arson Conspiracy. The fact that he has blue eyes suggests that, at some other time he killed an innocent.

The only candidate we've seen him kill on screen that might fit that bill is his niece Laura who he killed BEFORE HE BECAME THE ALPHA.

I hope that clears up the question. This thread is closed.