Board Thread:False Info and Speculative Discussion/@comment-2245905-20140610223340/@comment-14168656-20140812150236

65.94.210.71 wrote: 174.92.158.240 wrote: I've already posted this on another thread but I think it might be a banshee. The third part of the list was already written or transcribed before Liam was bitten, so the Benefactor must have predicted or sensed that Scott would bite Liam. Another point, the name that unlocked the third part of the list was who Lydia (who- might I remind you- is a banshee!!) predicted would be the next murder. Also, how was the Benefactor able to get in touch with Meredith the way they did?? They themselves would have to be a banshee because, as far as we know, humans and other supernatural creatures cannot interact with basnhees that way. I WAS  R I G H T. EVERYONE SCROLLED PAST THIS AND DIDN'T GIVE IT A SECOND THOUGHT You might be right, but we don't know who the benefactor is yet. And a few things

1) We don't know whether Liam was added to the list before he was bitten. The comment was made that they don't know how the list is "updated" Remember Liam was on the third part. We do not have any reason (at this point) to assume that he was added prior to being bitten.

2) We don't have any reason to believe that a Banshee would know when someone is going to get bit/ become supernatural. Remember the line in the scene from next week. Banshees sense Death. It has never been implied that they could sense someone was going to turn.

3) We don't know whether Lydia's grandmother is the benefactor or just was/is working FOR the benefactor. Keep in mind Lydia's name is on the list. We don't know anything about her grandmother, so it's possible she wouldn't hire a hit man to kill her own granddaughter.