Board Thread:False Info and Speculative Discussion/@comment-1962215-20140812025444/@comment-11533671-20140817162716

LadyX wrote: Personally I think Fenris is giving the writers a little too much credit for the shock factor. He does fit nicely...they've just...they always get the flurry of speculation going, and have never actually thrown a big curve ball at us on the reveal. They've always went with the 'too obvious' choice in the end. I always figured the Kanima was Jackson and Jennifer was the Darach, Peter was mildly surprising, but was still on my list in s1, because I though Deaton was going to be it, which would've been the most obvious choice. The only real surprise was Noshiko being the one at the Nemeton, but that was more random and weird than surprising to me.

I actually couldn't agree more. Ditto with previous main villain guesses, although as soon as Derek took Scott to see his uncle I totally stopped speculating about anyone else.

This is exactly why I say Fenris is a stab in the dark...I mean why go with a complete surprise like this (or someone else we wouldn't think about) when you could use the obvious choices of Gerard, Harris, Peter, etc.? lol