Board Thread:WARNING - SPOILERS and FALSE INFO AHEAD/@comment-108.81.117.0-20130717021251/@comment-190.53.126.199-20150705053406

they are even in terms of power it would all go down to their fighting skills in which i would say derek gets the edge as we saw when he managed to hold his own against 2 beserkers as a beta teenager while scott couldn't handle 1 as a alpha also from what i can gather derek has more brute strength than scott as we saw how he managed to hold down liam while was lossing his power, liam who is stated that is the stronger werewolf derek has seen at his age. People seem to think that a true alpha is more powerfull than a regular alpha which is false as it has never been stated as such. They are just rare nothing else same way that turning into a full wolf as derek can do is rare but doesn't mean that someone is more powerfull it's just kind of a status and gains them repect in the werewolf community.

so in the end in a morals off confrontation i would say that derek would win although it would be a close fight as although derek has superior fighting skills and strength scott is no slouch in both departments as we see when he defeated peter who is a highly skilled and strong werewolf