Board Thread:False Info and Speculative Discussion/@comment-207.254.224.12-20140717193212/@comment-24463749-20140718225725

Paul.rea wrote:

92.0.157.103 wrote:

what about Scott vs kincaid, Scott vs the berserkers, Scott vs the Oni and Scott vs the Wendigo who got murdered by the mute a whole family of them but scott couldnt handle 1 but you still refuse to see the problem they're trying to point out We don't have another Alpha fighting Kincaid - we have no idea if a "strong alpha" would do better.

Derek was knocked out by the Oni - Scott got stabbed while distracted during a fight with the Oni - same outcome.

And while we don't have another Alpha/Wendigo fight to compare - I think it is fair to say that Scott had his hands full trying to save Liam so I don't know what you expected him to do in this situation.

Again - we're talking about "strong" or "weak" when it comes to the Alphas seen on the show. In head to head comparisons - Scott is average. kincaid himself asked where scott strength was... the twins who were omegas took him out easily

fair enough but then again in the season finally divine move didnt the omega twins and derek were holding off the onis easily but were having problems because the oni weren't dieing? So going by the logic of alpha  beta  omega, if omegas are able to hold them off shouldnt alphas make short work of them

if scott had  actually faught the wendigo in the passage in the first palce wendigo wouldnt have gotten to liam

and yh it is in the terms of weak since the mute has no super human strength but he was able to take the who family out who peter was able to fight off with a axe in his chest and who derek beat easily as well and based on what the show has been saying since season 1 alpha are the most powerful most feirce of the werewolves