Board Thread:False Info and Speculative Discussion/@comment-2245905-20140610223340/@comment-25243147-20140801113439

Here is another way to eliminate. Look at the mystery Big Bads from seasons 1, 2, and 3A. One trait they share is that the character was introduced in that season. Here are the new characters in S4 that are still living:

Brett Talbot (beta) (2 appearances so far, in episodes 5 and 6) Deputy Haigh (sheriff's deputy) (1 appearance, in episode 2) Dr. Geyer (stepfather of Liam) (1 appearance, in episode 3) Mason (friend of Liam) (3 appearances, in episodes 4, 5, and 6) Ms. Fleming (math teacher) (2 appearances, in episodes 3 and 6)

Brett is on the Deadpool, and he was almost killed already, so he doesn't seem likely. Teen Wolf needs an openly gay character, so eliminate Mason. In episode 6, Meredith said the Benefactor was a "he", so that leaves Deputy Haigh and Dr. Geyer.

Maybe we should wait and see which of the two makes another appearance? In the S4 midseason trailer, Deputy Haigh shows up in shot 39 (at 1:01 in the video), and I think that shot is from E09 (about time to reveal the Big Bad). However, Dr. Geyer might make a more interesting Benefactor.