Board Thread:WARNING ALL USERS False Info\Spoilers/@comment-24132585-20140218132556/@comment-27058022-20151009100841

What if Malia was adopted by Mr Tate and his wife but the sister is biological. If this is true then maybe it was the wife that wanted to adopt and Mr Tate didn't.

You know how Malia was admitted to Eichen House, why would Mr Tate do this after his daughter was found. what if Mr Tate doesen't care for her all that much and wishes that it was his wife and other dauughter (possibly biological) that survived. he was very emotional when the doll was found probably more so than when malia was found or so it seemed.

Unless she acted odd but im not sure if there was really enough time for that (on the Eichen House admission)

But yeah either way Mr Tate does seem sketchy and looks it too.