Board Thread:Legitimate Canon Questions/@comment-24598128-20140227042520/@comment-74.14.80.148-20141222191916

They barely show off Scott's strength, so this is a tough call. Story wise, it seems like Deucalion, "the alpha of alphas", is supposed to be the strongest werewolf. He is so far unbeaten by anybody and he has his vision.

If it was a human-form fight, Season 4 Scott would easily take down Season 1 Peter. It seems like he almost mastered his powers to the level where he could dodge all of Peter's moves without a sweat. This is just a hint of what he could do if he is focused.

Peter's monster form brings a dynamic where it is too hard to do damage because he is bigger, more versatile and possibly faster. It was also hinted in Season 4 that Scott could shift further (when he beat the crap out of that mercenary, shifting more into a Deucalion-like state). If he could dodge beast Peter with the same level of skill and success rate, slashing him would be easy since he is a much larger target.

Then again, the best we've seen Alphas Scott fight was against Omega Peter, so Alpha Peter would probably smash him.