Board Thread:False Info and Speculative Discussion/@comment-4723271-20161221191550/@comment-26879545-20161228162526

Honestly, though. At the very least, he should be... (skeptical? suspicious?) I can't think of the right word, right now... But he should at least find it odd that his father, in a lucid moment, revealed that his wife, that he (Noah) sleeps next to, sees every day, is actually dead and he has a son.

Sure, Elias has dementia, but as we've seen, he was lucid, he was throwing shade at everyone and their parents, he was, for all intents and purposes, there, in the moment. It doesn't help that Elias immediately went "docile" (for lack of a better term) after that outburst.

Also, isn't he suspicious over how Claudia is still alive when she had that fatal strain of dementia? Even Melissa found it weird/strange/a miracle that she was still alive after having seen it on her medical records...

I mean, sure, the Sheriff deserves nice things, but from a logical standpoint, this entire situation throws up way too many red flags, and the fact that the Sheriff, supposedly, can't see that is baffling to me.