Board Thread:Legitimate Canon Questions/@comment-25044452-20140703201309/@comment-13965604-20140707034125

Killer kev wrote: LadyX wrote: 99.170.226.119 wrote: Lydia & Allison both held up their pictures in the episode "Letharia Vulpina" with Lydia saying that they were father & daughter.

Name: Sean

That doesn't prove that they know it's her, that proves they think it's her, because they kind of have the same attitude look on their faces in the pictures. There are definitely similarities in their two pictures. That does prove that they KNOW its her, when Lydia threw talia's nails into the wooden post the whispers had to have told her that Malia was peter's daughter because if the whispers didn't tell her that how else would they know it was Malia, thousands of people live within beacon hills and your saying that they guessed that a werecoyote with zero previous connection to peter is his daughter

It proves they're good at deducing things. The only other known were-creature in town is a pretty reasonable guess, especially when she's got the same bitch face as Peter in their photos. I'm not saying she's not, I just don't think Talia's claws told Lydia for sure who it was specifically. We don't know how old Malia would've been when the memories were removed or even if she were born yet to have a name, or if Talia knew the name. I freely admit at this time we have no reason to doubt it is Malia based on what we have so far. I just wouldn't be the slightest bit surprised if they threw us a curve ball and she not be his kid and it be someone else.