Board Thread:WARNING - SPOILERS and FALSE INFO AHEAD/@comment-108.81.117.0-20130717021251/@comment-6068707-20140330235608

Derek was a werewolf long before Scott. Aside from that, Derek doesn't get caught up in his morals. He has a set plan and follows it. Derek isn't afraid of getting into a fight and isn't afriad of having to kill someone in a fight.

Scott on the other hand, has been a wolf for a little over a year now. He's been a beta wolf, unwillingly and had and experience of being called and placed as an Omega. Although he's been and Omega, he hasn't experienced the actual life style of being an Omega, one that is completely alone. They call it the lone wolf for a reason and he hasn't had to run and hide away from hunters, like Derek had to at one point in his life.

Derek had had training and has had the understanding of how to be a strong leader. Scott can be a leader but he doesn't know how to be a strong leader, I.E. the questions and the need to always wonder about everything.

I'd say Derek's superior intellect on being a wolf, will fall into place in this kind of fight and because of this, Derek could and wouldn't even hesitate to go all out aside from the sentimental understanding of Scott as a packmate, a fellow wolf and probably even a bit like a brother.

Derek would win in an all or nothing fight. But considering Scott is an Alpha, if he were to embrace it more, it could turn out differently probably near death tie?

Nah. I vote Derek wins. He's also better as an Alpha.