Board Thread:False Info and Speculative Discussion/@comment-2245905-20140806211028/@comment-13965604-20140807193433

BoricuaWolf wrote: LadyX wrote:

BoricuaWolf wrote: Deputy jackass (he serves no purpose unless they're going to kill him)

Orderly

Gerard

Mr Tate

Liam's step dad

Whoever it is, I think that they are not who they seem. None of these people really have motive and I can't think of who could be connected to the passwords (since I was wrong about them all being connected to Lydia). Gerard definitely has motive.

Yep, my mistake there. If it were him it wouldn't require any explanation of motive. He actually would make the most sense,

-The fact that he hasn't attacked yet when he wanted to "Kill them ALL!" always felt like a plot hole to me.

-He would hate all the supernatural

-He believes paying someone else to take out an enemy is a good strategy

-He would know how to manipulate Kate

-People were expecting him to be a villan in Season 3 but he never was so it takes hi a little off the radar

There are only 2 reasons I could see it not being him. 1) It makes too much sense (Teen wolf usually doesn't LOL). 2) I just can't figure someone who would be connected to Allison, Aiden, & Derek.

PS Mr. Tate kind of has some motive too.

Mr. Tate always gave me an odd vibe. I found the way his guard dog stopped barking strange when he yelled at it when the boys were breaking in. A guard dog shouldn't stop announcing until the owner sees what it's barking at, or it should attack it. Not just wimper and walk away. There is a potential for motive, the supernatural killed his wife and child thing is certainly valid.

After seeing the three keys I think we can't put any stock in them. There is no common tying feature. They aren't all closely connected in any way. They aren't all close to Lydia, they didn't all die in the same season, they aren't all dead, or alive. It was weak writing. Three should be able to establish a pattern, and their choices didn't do that.