Board Thread:False Info and Speculative Discussion/@comment-24548301-20140717040306/@comment-4091815-20140718015621

LadyX wrote:

Nick Rucci wrote:

Mesmermann wrote: We saw only The Mutes latest list. But why didn't the Mute kill Scott? Scott wasn't worth as much as the Wilcott Family together they were worth $100,0000 Even assuming those numbers represented prices, that still doesn't explain why, while he had the opportunity, he didn't take Scott out too. Yes. Assuming the numbers are monetary compensation, the Wolcotts were worth more, making it sensible to hit them first. But when he was on the roof to kill the boy, and Scott was right there, he didn't take the chance to get that 'bonus.' He chose to just shush him instead. No matter what those number represent, it doesn't make sense that he didn't try to take Scott out at the same time, while he was there, and stunned, when he was on the same list.

And to repeat - that wasn't the Mute's list - it was the one Lydia got in her head from the Banshee Whispers.