Board Thread:False Info and Speculative Discussion/@comment-24439517-20140714080003/@comment-14168656-20140715151245

Bennett89 wrote: My argument is based more off of his fights with people who should be way stronger than him. Ennis and Kali should be WAY stronger than Derek was as an Alpha but he held his own (esp against Ennis) who was more of a power fighter. I say held his own each time bc when he lost there was always a variable such as Kali having a Pipe or Them using the water and electricity mid-fight.

You can use that same argument to discredit me by saying Scott was on par with Ennis at the warehouse, but look how easily Enis manhandled him in the elevator and also Beta Scott had more confidence in his abilities than ALpha Scott which translates to him being better as a beta bc he was more in control

I definitely see what your saying. I do think that there is a tendency to forget that Kali & Ennis were super Alphas (had killed their packs), so that does give them the advantage. Derek should get some points for that, no doubt.

I just think that even considering the confidence issues the way they portrayed Kincaid I don't see Beta Scott really standing a chance with Kincaid either. Also the way he manhandled Isaac in Silver Finger just makes me think his size ight just be too much even for some Alphas.

The truth is we're both just speculating. It would be nice if they'd bring Kincaid back so we could get some more comparisons. But just going off of the fact that it takes two wolves to take him down. I'd still put my money on him. But who knows your could be right.