Board Thread:False Info and Speculative Discussion/@comment-78.0.215.197-20150202084809/@comment-6383956-20150301121620

Stileswolf wrote: however I just realised wolves are actually able to communicate with the living once they are deceased in certain circumstances, remember in season 3 when Derek wanted to talk to his mother and they used her claws " I have to ask her somthing, and from what I've heard this is the only way it's possible" And his mother's claws had to be in his neck the entire time. He hasn't been in communication with his mother since they came out of his neck.

And Paul, I'll repeat because you don't seem to get it..... this doesn't match the five things you're talking about. At all.

1) We have no indication Peter was deprived of full moons. If being underground deprives a wolf of full moons, then why wouldn't the Alpha pack just keep its prisoners underground somewhere? Why would wolves react to the full moon when they're completely inside -- like Derek's pack members in S2 when they were inside the train car inside the warehouse?

2) Never ever ever ever ever has anyone healed by grabbing a hold of someone else. (And we also have it canonically confirmed beyond any shadow of a doubt that the kind of healing you're talking about would have extinguished Derek's Alpha spark.)

3) We also don't have any confirmation of any kind that someone who is 100% confirmed to be dead (by the fact that someone else got their Alpha spark) can just heal themselves back to life.

4) Werewolves manipulation of people's minds has always required their claws to enter the base of their neck. Peter bit Lydia with his teeth on her shoulder.

5) We have zero evidence that werewolves can continue to communicate psychically after death without having their claws imbedded in someone's neck. (As noted above.)

And since you have no explanation for any of these differences, continuing to harp on how that's the canonical explanation is..... frankly, it's dumb.

The only aspect of this that you're trying to peddle to us that I can't argue with is that we've seen wolfsbane heal (well, mostly been told it can heal but it's still canon) and it was present at Peter's resurrection. But nothing else at all matches up with what we've seen in canon. Nobody's looking for a non-canonical explanation. There is not a canonical one. You have your theory. But that it all that it is -- theory.