Board Thread:False Info and Speculative Discussion/@comment-16083651-20170111164432/@comment-4723271-20170115021826

I'd have no problem with Scott not killing if he was actually successful in doing so. By this I mean if he kept the body count of his villains to a minimum, but that's almost never the case. Bodies are dropping, and Scott enforcing his rule of no killing isn't saving anyone.

I did get that impression, and I hate it so much. Right before his sister killed him for the last time, he kinda just gave in, like he realized he deserved it. I feel like the writers wanted people to feel bad for him, and from what I've been seeing online, it's working. I hate most redemption arcs. I like the bad guys, so I'm naturally against this.

Those creatures of the week episodes really didn't get the job done for most viewers, you'd think they had learned from the assassin of t he week fail. S5 was most definitely rushed. There may have been no indication that Gerard would betray them but it's not far-fetched.

You're right, it wouldn't hurt to show someone like Theo can be capable of goodness but I'd rather them do it with someone else, like Peter. They seem to be taking a similar route with him anyways.