Board Thread:False Info and Speculative Discussion/@comment-24.130.28.230-20150721180826/@comment-26872127-20160103172700

C'mon. I love speculating about banshees just as everyone here especailly now that Lydia has new powers which seem to come from Vallack. (He said he amplified her powers.) But we are trying to solve a schrodinger's cat. Unless someone in the future of the show actually says it out loud that banshees are/are not supernatural, we are going to be sitting here arguing about it. Paul backs himself up with recent canon. We try to back ourselves with what was said in season 4 and before and we are both going around in circles. Let's stop arguing because it won't get us anywhere untill the show says it right at our face.

-Paul says banshees are not supernatural because they can cross mountain ash. He is right in this context.

-We say that banshees are because they have powers and are obviously not entirely human.

-The show either contradicted itself or it will go to the long list of plotholes we have or they did it on purpose.

But the point is: It doesn't actually make a difference on screen. If banshees are exceptions to the rules, or if they are not supernatural then the outcome is still the same on screen what we see untill there is a scene that actually needs it explained.

I'll stick with banshees being supernatural but I accept Pauls view on the things because he has a point. So let's wait it out and hope that the show actually says it out straight for once. :)