Board Thread:False Info and Speculative Discussion/@comment-24.130.28.230-20150721180826/@comment-4295751-20150724042810

I know what Deaton said. I was there. He said "a line no supernatural creature should be able to cross", leaving room for doubt. Just like how sure he was when he made the Japanese translation. But how many times so far Lydia proved to be an exception to those rules of supernatural? The bite either kills you, or turns you. The kanima venom paralyzes everyone but the kanima. And then there is the mountain ash. I know the last one wasn't made a big deal on screen, but it doesn't matter. The power that makes Lydia a banshee allows her to get a free pass when it comes to rules of supernatural. Everything on the show but that one line of Deaton, who is not even sure of the things he say, tells us banshees are supernatural. So I see 2 options here:

- Banshees are supernatural, but rules of supernatural do not apply to them

- It's a contradiction, that is deliberately kept a contradiction for the sake of consistency

Unless Jeff Davis himself tells that banshees are not supernatural, I will keep believing and saying that she is. Sorry Paul, but I'm big on logic. And logic tells me that one who can create blast forces with her hands and can sense death cannot pass as human.