Board Thread:False Info and Speculative Discussion/@comment-24.130.28.230-20150721180826/@comment-5237598-20160202120103

Pleaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaase stop!!!!! This is getting ridiculous! I went to sleep last night, when i got up this morning 52 mails were in my inbox, all about this thread... And you guys have basically been turning in circles for the last couple of days. You will never agree, so why argue?

Please let me repeat what I have said before. The Show is not consistant in its Story telling.

Deaton stated that no supernatural creature can (or should be able to) cross a mountain ash barrier. This is a fact. Deaton is an emissary and very knowledgeable about the supernatural. Therefore this Statement has validity => it is Canon. The logical conclusion would be, anything that can cross mountain ash is not supernatural.

Onis are Spirits. Are they supernatural? The mountain ash test was not conclusive. Eventhough the mountain ash stopped them in the beginning, they had no Trouble breaking the barrier. Now you may argue that Spirits are not supernatural creatures... But what's a kitsune? A Fox Spirit... Kitsune are supernatural beings since Kira could not pass the mountain ash...

I think it's fair too say werewolves are supernatural creatures. Yet Scott was able to pass the mountain ash in order to get to Jennifer. Yes I know, Scott's a true Alpha, which means that some rules don't apply to him, BUT he is still a supernatural creature! To me this fact contradicts the set up rules.

The chimeras... a topic that bothers me... The Argument that those hybrids were created through science and therefore they are not supernatural is ridiculous. Just because they were injected with the supernatural DNA and weren't turned by a supernatural creature does not mean they are not supernatural. It does not make any sense at all to me. They are still half werewolf half were Coyote, half werewolf hald kanima etc... All supernatural creatures. According to the Canon though, they are not. AND this was illustrated at least twice by letting Theo walk over the mountain ash, a reminder and "proof" that chimeras are not supernatural in the TW Universe...

Why am I listing all of These examples and illustrations? To Show you guys that the TW Canon often does not make any sense. I've said it before and I'll probably say it again, TW shows absolutely no consistancy, and rules will be ignored if the Story "needs" it. So here'y my Statement: According to the TW rules, supernatural beings cannot pass mountain ash. THIS IS CANON. BUT IT DOES NOT MAKE ANY SENSE. You guys will probably ignore my post and keep on arguing, but I've done my best to put this (imo) useless discussion to an end. As far as I am concerned, both parties are partially right. Blame the show and its writers for your disagreement.