Board Thread:False Info and Speculative Discussion/@comment-4295751-20150811205600/@comment-4091815-20150814223944

we have every reason to believe that your scenario is not what the writers intended because, as we've seen with subsequent props, they have a superhuman inability to nail down specific years etc.

While some of the current ages of characters is known, actual birth years for characters are not canonical because they require us to do math and supply other information not specifically presented on the show.

You have a strong opinion about this issue and it seems to be clouding your usual "show me a source" attitude about stuff on this site.

I would ask that you please remain unemotional on this issue, especially after I remove this entire thread.