Board Thread:False Info and Speculative Discussion/@comment-6529205-20140419164329/@comment-13965604-20140716153312

203.206.98.224 wrote: LadyX wrote:

Grahamburglar wrote:

LadyX wrote:

Now, Malia herself might not have been so bad, if my suspension of disbelief wasn't already cracked from what I, and others, consider a lack of consistency. Paul.rea disagrees, and he's entitled to his opinion, but that doesn't change the fact that that's how it reads to multiple fans. The school thing also might not have been so bad if they actually addressed why she was there instead of being privately tutored, or showed she was in special ed classes. You mean like instead of blatantly showing us she was in math with all the other kids, and showing the teacher -- who we have to believe would be aware of her situation (what kind of school wouldn't tell the teachers "your new student was living on her own in the woods for eight years"?) -- made her go up to the board and do a problem in front of the entire rest of the class? And I'm pretty sure we're not going to get a scene later where Mr. Tate tries to get that teacher fired even though I'd say that's the appropriate response. Exactly. Tell us she was a math genius before, and that they think the best way to help her is throw her back into it head first, at the very least. Again, more believable would be special ed, but at least give us something to grasp on to. But even given a "plausible " explanation, there was no excuse for putting her on the blackboard, and any parent, even a bad one, would recognize that was abusive. You all missed the fact that Lydia gave her the answer at the black board. Stiles, Lydia and Kira are all helping her blend in and keep afloat. I wouldn't be surprised if the Sherrif was involved behind the scenes too. All that troublesome paperwork. What I want to know is, who is she living with?

No, actually, we didn't forget. The point is, realistically, the school system and any agencies interested in her wouldn't and shouldn't throw her into high school and expect a few teenagers to get her up to speed from an elementary education. Besides, teacher didn't approve the help, she expected her to know it.

I don't know why you would think she's staying with anyone other than her dad Mr. Tate, who lives in town, and should've been beyond happy to have a member of his lost family returned to him.