Board Thread:False Info and Speculative Discussion/@comment-4091815-20160202180218/@comment-7603754-20160202204557

HolyDrumstick wrote: The point, as always, is that it was posted before it was verified canon.

Now it is verified, and can be stated as canon.

I don't care if Lydia and banshees are supernatural, non-supernatural, Oompaloompas, or Asgardian.

The only thing I care about is that we're all held to the same standards about what can be called canon, and that Paul considers what other people have to say about that. We aren't, and he doesn't.

An email making his theory canon does not change that. No, the underlying problem hasn't changed, but now you don't have a banner to rally people with.