Board Thread:False Info and Speculative Discussion/@comment-31079951-20170118192820/@comment-11533671-20170122055408

Kev - I removed my post before u replied, mainly because AOA and your other post already addressed the issues. Sorry for any confusion!

The legend says they take ppl, we've since found out they erase them. Since the legend is so old surely others have tried to stop them before and IF they killed others before then the bodies would've been found and a whole mess of questions would've resulted like, "Why are these dead people the only ones left in this place?" And IF that happened then why isn't that ever mentioned when that would've been an odd occurrence on top of the already odd disappearances and probably would've been worth noting.

At least I would think ppl would've passed on that little tidbit as an afterthought like, "The GRs and The Wild Hunt take people except on the few occasions where it looks as though they just killed them instead."

My point is that we're told they take ppl and have never heard or seen otherwise. Why would they even try killing Scott and Co when they could just easily take them and be done with it?

Logically it follows that they were sent to kill them since they've not acted outside of their "taking" protocol before that we know of. Whether or not this is true is yet to be seen but it makes sense given what we know. What doesn't make any sense is that they somehow feel so threatened or hindered by Scott that they decide, "Gee this kid keeps fucking with us, let's just kill him and forget taking him into our train station to join our Hunt. Oh and let's do it once Douglas and the Hellhound have come through the rift."