Board Thread:False Info and Speculative Discussion/@comment-25176701-20150818031151/@comment-13965604-20150823144346

And now it feels like Sean is trolling. We know Stiles did all this, we have reason to not trust him should he be a real person that we meet in real life. But Scott doesn't know the things we know.

Stiles hid what he did. That's not out right lying. No one ever was like "yo, Stiles, you know what happened to Donovan?" For him to lie about it. As soon as someone questioned him about it, he admitted it.

From Scott's position of what he knew, Stiles deserved some sort of benefit of the doubt, which he didn't give. He didn't ask what happened. Stiles did wrong in that convo too, don't get me wrong, but Scott could've definitely approached it differently.