Board Thread:False Info and Speculative Discussion/@comment-192.230.165.112-20140420035210/@comment-6383956-20140619030021

And yet, you've utterly failed to provide any examples to prove your point.

Name just one culture on the planet Earth where someone would say "when I lived with my dad" and mean that they were living with both planets. Seriously, I'll even give you time to research. You will not find it. Because people do not speak that way.

And, again, are the ways you describe parts of your life incidental? Do you accidentally say "When I had my own apartment" instead of "when I lived with three roommates"? No, you don't.

And you can keep arguing that it isn't inconsistent but it is. Because characters speak like people do (if the writers have even the remotest bit of talent) and there is not a person on this planet that would say something that misleading.

Give it up, Paul.