Board Thread:False Info and Speculative Discussion/@comment-24.130.28.230-20150721180826/@comment-27547895-20160202011214

Paul.rea wrote:

The latest canon is that nothing supernatural can cross mountain ash. Actually, the latest canon is that Deaton said that nothing supernatural SHOULD be able to cross mountain ash. Addtional recent canon is that Deaton has admitted that things in the supernatural world may be different than he understands them to be. Not that that was needed for it to be canon that Deaton is not always correct.

You can't make Deaton's word canon as long as it is canon that Deaton is not always 100% accurate, especially when you are applying what he said to someone and something that was not mentioned in the conversation you are using to create said canon.

You can simply say "according to Deaton" or "if Deaton is 100% accurate...."

You refuse to do so only out of your stubborn refusal to admit that you are wrong.