Board Thread:WARNING ALL USERS False Info\Spoilers/@comment-92.238.137.64-20140207010708/@comment-13965604-20140211230507

141.0.8.139 wrote: I think that he isn't Scott's biological father, Scott is really a Hale whose mom had an affair with Talia's husband, and Talia told Derek that Scott is his brother. Is it me or is Derek incredibly kind to Scott lately?

Derek always wanted Scott to be like a brother to him, Scott's the one that didn't want anything to do with Derek, so Derek moved on and treated him like the outsider he wanted to be. Now Scott wants some guidance and help, and oh guess what let's use Derek when we need him.

Technically if your theory were true, Scott wouldn't be a Hale, because that's Peter and Talia's surname, not Derek's father's. The only way for him to be a Hale was if Peter was his dad, or one of the other born Hales in the fire.

Also, why would Agent McCall be so desperate to be a part of Scott's life now, and mend the fences, if he weren't his father?