Board Thread:False Info and Speculative Discussion/@comment-4723271-20170113132704/@comment-7603754-20170113192314

Well, that all depends on why Lydia remembered the Jeep. If it's because she's a banshee then, yeah, it doesn't make sense. However, if she remembered the connection because she loved him, then it would explaine Mason recognizing the phone... although it would have helped if Teen Wolf had shown Corey having an attachment to the phone, since we've seen Stiles being as in love with his Jeep as he is with Scott or Lydia.