Board Thread:False Info and Speculative Discussion/@comment-2245905-20140806211028/@comment-25222572-20140810010725

Jestermonkey4u wrote:

JEK wrote:

KapitanGowno wrote: Ok.....

WHY SO MANY PEOPLE THINK IT IS HARRIS?

He was Darach's sacrifice for "Soldier". As far as I remember - you had to SACRIFICE someone (means - KILL HIM to death) and she did it. There was no report of other soldier sacrifice commited later, so he was the last one. Also, we saw him tied to the tree, killed with garrote.

My bets are on Deucalion (for real). He was in Season 3 (someone posted, rumors are the Benefactor was in season 3), we have NO idea what happened ot him later. He also hired Breaden for uncertain and unknow reasons AND he has perfect motif to kill Scott's pack (obviously, he hates them for stopping him). He could know about supernatural beings also.

Much better villain for me than Mr Harris Brought this up on another thread. Went through and showed how little sense it made. Of course, this is Teen Wolf, so they could pull it off if they wanted. Just have to stretch that whole suspension of disbelief thing until it snaps. If by showing everyone how ridiculous the notion of Harris seems by asserting he died, then eh...no.

Scott, Allison and Stiles' ice bath journey was a true sacrifice that opened up the Nemeton so-to-speak. Their sacrifice alone was enough to give Jennifer power so IF Harris simply was miraculously saved or survived - it wouldn't matter for the Darachs plan. In fact the trio's sacrifice would have been all that was needed to satisfy th ritual.

Furthermore, without a dead body (or even as LadyX stated, WITH one, as in Kate's case) there still exists the possibility and it really isn't as absurd as you spin it. After all Kate, Peter and Jennifer have all survived "certain" death b4.

Even as Scott, Allison and Stiles showed us...it IS entirely possible for one to die, albeit briefly, and still survive under special circumstances. IF Harris was choked to that brink and still revived - wouldn't his "dying" have still counted for sacrificial reasons? Sure worked for our heroes.

This is NOT...I repeat NOT, a 100% certainty but neither is it stretching our disbelief any further than we've experienced 3 times previously!

Tbh, it would be pretty much on par for TW so in that regard is why I hesitate to whole-heartedly believe in it. Ressurecting the dead has been done too much already on TW - thus making Harris a less desirable candidate (along with Peter being so obvious) but still a much more valid guess than others I've seen. You make some good points, even some I've considered previously, but discarded (mainly because I didn't think they would go the resurrection route that many times in a single season).

But I just want to make a slight correction. Remember, Scott, Stiles, and Allsion fed power back to the Nemeton, but not to Jennifer. If you recall, she was still not at full strength during her final encounter with Deucalion.

Also, it is reasonably absurd, but it's also Teen Wolf, who engages in the absurd on a regular basis, so I'll grant that that is no reason to disbelieve something.