Board Thread:Legitimate Canon Questions/@comment-25044452-20140703201309/@comment-13965604-20140704184220

Nick Rucci wrote: IJacksonVan wrote: Jestermonkey4u wrote: It would be sort of crazy IF Malia didn't turn out to be his daughter, I mean I don't recall if Lydia actually got the name or if she just assumed that the child Talia removed from Peter's memory was her. Imo it is Malia until proven otherwise but it would make a surprising twist if it happened. Yeah, I've also wondered that....

Lydia just took a good guess.

well Malia was a werecoyote and that power had to come from somewhere, Peter would obviosuly be her father, and the fact that we don't know what Lydia heard from Talia's claws, she probably was told exactly who it was

That's just conjecture. Fact is we don't know what Lydia heard, or anything about Malia's mother, and very little about the father she knows. I still think it was odd how the dog stopped barking when there was an intruder in the house, just because Mr. Tate told him to from another room.