Board Thread:False Info and Speculative Discussion/@comment-24.130.28.230-20150721180826/@comment-27547895-20160131180229

Paul.rea wrote:

It actually doesn't matter if they were both sloppy. What was said is canon unless they recon it later. So, you're actually admitting that your theory is just a theory?

I mean, if sloppy writing was responsible, then what IS and IS NOT supernatural doesn't change. What IS supernatural now will be later and what IS NOT now will not be later. You are applying information regarding chimeras to Lydia and banshees in general, when they weren't even mentioned. You are assuming that this piece of the puzzle is a universal absolute. Now, it would be different if they had directly addressed banshees.... then it wouldn't be an assumption, but they didn't.

Also, I seriously doubt that Lydia's grandmother built her mountain ash boathouse herself, with her own two hands. That in itself is a bit of a stretch. As far as the urn... it's just as plausible that she had that arranged, too. So, don't try spewing that nonsense as an absolute, either. The point is that things could be different than how we understand them, at this point.

The POINT is that you really can't say you 100% know that banshees are not supernatural according to Teen Wolf canon, because there are other things that are possible, and banshees (or Lydia for that matter) have not been directly and explicitly addressed by the show.

Your THEORY is based on applying a conversation about chimeras to a person and creature type that was not mentioned in any of those conversations. And it is just a theory. If anyone else did this, you'd delete the posts because "headcanon and fanfiction, grrrrrr." You KNOW that.