Board Thread:False Info and Speculative Discussion/@comment-4148963-20141115141915/@comment-4723271-20141219025358

JEK wrote: Killer kev wrote: Grahamburglar wrote: Killer kev wrote: 217.34.19.184 wrote: Whatever dude - Season 5 will prove you wrong ^Exactly, its like he completely forgot what happen in the season finale, scott's obivously not the weakest Or possibly, they're not willing to let a single five minute fight outweigh four years of watching Scott be pitiful. :P We will see in Season 5, but there's no way of knowing that wasn't some berserker-induced fluke that will never happen again. " four years of watching scott be pitiful " what show have you been watching? Scott didnt become pitiful until 3b, in seasons 1,2, and 3a, scott was far from pitiful He was never particularly strong either. He was alright in S1-2 (though he still managed to get his ass kicked in most of his fights; with the notable exception of his 1v2 Isaac/Erica smackdwon. Oh, and that one time when he bitchslapped Isaac off-screen and tossed him out the front door of his house. Which, I'll grant, was amusing). He spent S3a not doing great, but slowly building up. However, the best we got from him was the mountain ash barrier (which was impressive) and a single moment of equalling Ennis.

But yeah, 3b was when he went from "alright, with the possibility of being more" to "downright pathetic". S4 somewhat turned that around, but he only really showed one instance of being worthy of the title of "Alpha". And we don't know if that was JUST him, or something to do with recently being a skull-headed rage monster. We're all hoping that he continues to be great, but.....well, some people are just pessimists. Don't call them idiots, Kev. They just don't have the same trust in the writer's as you do. I agree, to say that scott was pitiful in seasons 1-3a is just wrong but he was super poerful either in those seasons, also I never called anyone an idiot, that was the other guy.