Board Thread:False Info and Speculative Discussion/@comment-128.163.7.156-20140915023057/@comment-5285305-20140918152730

Paul.rea wrote: Why did he then give the knife to Malia to take the killing blow? I just rewatched the episode, and you're right Paul. He said "Aim for the skull. Kill it it. Do it now" when giving her the dagger.

This doesn't make sense then. If he just wanted Scott out of the way why did he say "Thank God" in Time of Death when told that Scott is still alive. I'm just willing to accept the writing this season wasn't great, and that there is a continuity error on Peter's character.