Board Thread:False Info and Speculative Discussion/@comment-25222572-20150608135325/@comment-71.236.1.182-20150616204227

199.168.73.11 wrote: I think what Stiles meant is a bit more that he feels it's his responsibility to check if Scott's faith in people is justified. Scott has an unflappable need to see good in people and to give them second chances, even if they didn't really do anything to deserve it (Deucalion and Jennifer being the most obvious. He was set to let Jennifer leave and never come back, before Deucalion killed her, and then Scott let Deucalion go anyway). It falls on Stiles to look farther than face value, to be suspicious, and maybe he's not always right, but Scott's just not really capable of even attempting it.

Scott is a great Alpha. He really cares for people and he wants to keep everyone safe, but the problem is, he really means EVERYONE. The most coniving thing we've seen him do was poisoning Gerard with mountain ash, but Gerard had already had a few chances and had proven too violent.

I think Scott and Stiles are just having a fight over Stiles' 'paranoia' with new people and Stiles is finally feed up with being told that he's worrying over nothing. It's not that Scott has faith in people. It's just he likes to give people the benefit of a doubt and believes in second chances. While Jennifer & Deucalion were bad guys. They weren't pure evil like Peter & Gerard. Also, don't forget that Scott was only going to let them go if they promised to stop doing what they were doing. He even threatened to kill them both if they didn't.

Scott has no problem with killing bad guys or letting them be killed. In fact Scott (like stiles) doesn't trust people either.but when stiles doesn't trust someone he refuses to work with them at all. while Scott is willing to not only work with them but use them to his(& the packs) advantage.

Aside from all that though I agree with you about Scott being a great alpha & about what they're arguing about.

~ Sean 😎