Board Thread:False Info and Speculative Discussion/@comment-194.169.217.207-20140701042129/@comment-10280603-20140702153120

LadyX wrote:

Grahamburglar wrote: Ep 1's issues were largely that not a damn thing the Mexican hunters do makes the slightest bit of sense.

Kate's scheme didn't make much sense, but since she was obviously not the one who planned the heist, I'm fairly certain that she was manipulated.

As far as Scott's dad, I don't think they would have told him anything. Scott still wants pretty much nothing to do with him, so why tell him anything? If he knew anything, he probably got told they were camping by Stiles' dad.

As for where the Sheriff thought they were camping, I'm not sure why that's something that's bothering you. Like, there's probably plenty of campgrounds around since they have plenty of woods. Or just the fact they have plenty of woods. (I'm more thinking like.... why did the anyone believe that Lydia would like camping? I love her but I just don't see her as "stay all night in the woods" kind of girl. :P) I mean, yea, Lydia's not a camping girl. It's just. My friends and have have done over night camping trips. But we've never done a weekend thing or longer like this would've needed to be. Googling directions from Redding CA (northern CA city), to Cananea Mexico (looks like a border town) is an 18 hour drive. I mean, we are talking nearly two days just in driving to and from, that doesn't include the time to scope the actual area, and come up with a solid plan. Then the detour to la inglesia which we don't know how far out of the way it was. I'm guessing at least an hour each way. They had to have been gone at least three days, if not four or five. And seeing as they were gone more than overnight, it makes sense that Scott's dad would know. Even if Scott doesn't like him, he would need to know to expect his son not to be around for a few days. I mean, he's FBI he knows about missing children and the first 24 hours being important. Someone would've told him. If Scott wouldn't, I'm sure Melissa would.

But, true about nothing the hunters doing making sense. That was so horrible my brain must've actually blocked it out. I think they were just mad that scott ran up in there territory like that