Board Thread:False Info and Speculative Discussion/@comment-4723271-20170918140954/@comment-13895380-20170924151254

Paul.rea wrote: Replace the word "explained" with "speculated" and the answer is yes, I did read what you wrote.

In your world it's impossible to sneak up on a distracted werewolf - if that were the case, there would be no hunters. No, you speculated that he came on foot in the first place. I explained that even in your speculated situation, it still wouldn't make sense. You said their werewolf senses need to be on in order to work..it was clearly on throughout the echolocation learning session. You said Scott and Malia sucked at echolocation; Scott learned it before Deucalion died (meaning that if a car or guy was sneaking up on them at that point, he should have heard it), Malia doesn't even need echolocation to hear someone within the region in a remote area...and are we going to ignore that Deucalion is a master at it?

And why would you assume that ONE guy came on foot in the first place? Oh that's right because you're fishing for a reason to appease your confirmation bias that the show is always consistent. Again, they didn't show the sound nor play the audio of the car that hit Liam until the last second, do you think it randomly appeared without no sound? Apparently you do.

No, in your world, everything that happens in the show is consistent, despite there being many inconsistencies throughout its seasons. You're trivializing everything. Hunters have traps. Hunters have devices that lure werewolves into traps. Hunters have poisons. Hunters have powerful weapons. You don't need to sneak up on anybody to use any of these. Yes, werewolves can be sneaked up on but given the context of the situation, it simply doesn't make much sense in this scene.