Board Thread:False Info and Speculative Discussion/@comment-26336987-20150702154624/@comment-4723271-20150703191542

Alpha-power-absorbing talons that didnt work as well as they should've, the doctors clearly arent as advanced as they think or the talons would've worked on Scott.

Ok, I'll give you that they are advanced, we know this but we still dont know what would be needed for moutain ash poisoning, that could be a reason why they wanted talons guy to take Scott's true alpha status, scott was able to break the mountain ash barrier, that could be something needed in curing the sickness.

All I'm saying is, however unlikely it is that Gerad is involved with the doctors, its still a possibility, you cant just rule it out.