Board Thread:WARNING ALL USERS False Info\Spoilers/@comment-25178327-20130920033551/@comment-1587802-20130920104210

I don't know what you mean by "chosen to lead the Alpha pack", because no one was chosen, it ended up being Deucalion, because it was Deucalion's idea. When he killed his beta, Marco, in 308, he discovered that he was stronger and faster and that he gained Marco's power. He convinced Ennis to do the same, and pulled Kali into the pack with the bait of Ennis being a part of it. They all killed all of their Beta's and now "super" Alpha's, they formed a "pack" (which I'm pretty sure isn't a technical functional pack, it's just a bunch of Alpha's hanging out together). I'm guessing this is when they found Ethan and Aiden and Deucalion taught them how to control their "Cale" ability and then they killed their rest of the pack, became Alphas, and joined the Alpha pack.

To answer your question of who would win in a fight, I'm not sure. Talia was looked up upon because of her wisdom, not fighting ability, I'm pretty sure, and as the matriarch of the Hale family, she effectively had a pack many times larger than Deucalion's (former) pack. But then again, Deucalion did have the Demon Wolf form, so I wonder.