Board Thread:False Info and Speculative Discussion/@comment-4091815-20140701192156/@comment-6383956-20140714141952

Paul.rea wrote: He didn't have his memory "wiped" at all. He's not a hard drive that can be reset to factory specs.

He was "regressed" to a certain age through means unknown and with side effects no one understands.

This is why you and LX are constantly disappointed - you are SOOOOO certain you understand how it worked even though nothing has been explained.

When your conclusion jumps prove to be wrong - you'll yell that it's a continuity error or bad writing when the real truth is you think you know but you don't. Paul, he remembered Kate.

He remembered kissing Kate.

He remembered Peter.

He remembered his house.

He did not remember the fire.

He did not remember that his family had been killed.

He did not remember that Kate was a hunter.

Like they really made it very clear that he "regressed" to that age in his memory. You think somehow the ONE memory that didn't regress was remembering that Kate knew he was a werewolf? That makes sense to you?

We're constantly disappointed because we expect the show to make some sense. Since you, apparently, think it's totally cool for professional writers being paid a great deal of money to write like junior high amateurs and not think through anything they're creating, no, you wouldn't be disappointed.