Board Thread:False Info and Speculative Discussion/@comment-2245905-20140610223340/@comment-4723271-20140817063854

LadyX wrote: Killer kev wrote: 108.45.131.87 wrote: Maybe it's Talia, and she's secretly alive with Lydia's grandmother.

Then again, I dunno why she would kill her own son but Peter isn't on the list soooo It cant be Talia bc Derek and Peter have her claws

Even humans can survive having their fingernails pulled. Why would you think a werewolf couldn't? The only real question would be 'can they grow back?'

Note: that was just for argument's sake. I don't really believe it's Talia. At all. I know a werewolf can survive having its claws pulled, I just don't think that Derek would've been able to communicate with Talia through her claws if she was alive