Board Thread:False Info and Speculative Discussion/@comment-50.117.41.228-20140326230237/@comment-13965604-20140327012800

Katie88Nisa wrote: why would he wanted to remember he had memory which his sister helped him took away?

Maybe I think Talia did a right thing because I believe it's better not have a father than have a bad one.

I agree about no father being better than a bad one, but the fact is, we don't know what kind of father he would have been. The fact is, he wasn't horrible enough of a person to keep him away from her own kids. Kids change people. She took the opportunity for him grow to be a better person away from him. The only way it's in the slightest way reasonable for her to have done that was if it was a mercy on his part because he was hurting so much from her presumed death. Other wise, my opinion of her changes because she had no right to make that decision. She is not god, or the child's mother, even. It changes her from a pure unsullied good leader to a controlling leader who may or may not be a tyrant.