Board Thread:False Info and Speculative Discussion/@comment-24732895-20160411234226/@comment-27565137-20160511201932

Honestlycynical wrote: Scott? Menacing? Are we both watching the same show? The only time he got close to menacing, IMHO, was when he was about to kill that Merecenary, and even that was short lived. We were finally close to getting something good (not "good" as in sunshine and rainbows, but "good" as in "hot damn, it's about bloody time") out of Scott and like... not even two seconds later he's back to playing the pacifist.

We all get that he's supposed to be some goody-two-shoes that doesn't want to kill, or whatever lame passive-aggressive stance he wants to follow, but having the power to actually fight back and being a killer are two entirely different things.

Not that this has anything to do with the thread topic, or even this conversation, but I'd much rather have had Stiles as a werewolf and Scott as the human. At least then we'd get more complex emotions instead of Scott's "don't kill, get laid, more passive-aggressiveness pls" life plan.

Also, you might want to watch what you say. We don't know if he'd "lose his True Alpha status" after killing someone. To say that he would lose it if he killed someone or stole their power is incorrect and could be seen as passing headcanon as canon. Yes. We're watching the same show, its only that we see things from different perspectives. Doesn't take a genius to see that.

Has for what I said about Scott possibility to lose his True Alpha power and become just a Alpha if he killed with the intention to steal someone else's power, wasn't something I just dreamt about.

If you remember, Deucalion main goal was for Scott to join his pack but he wanted Scott to do so by killing. Which later another character, Deaton or Breaden if I'm not mistaken, said that Deucalion wanted Scott to kill so Scott could never achieve his true potential. So if killing would have stop Scott from becoming a True Alpha, then it isn't so far fetched to arrive at the logical conclusion that if Scott were to kill not to protect or defend someone but with the intent on stealing the power of another werewolf, that could (emphasis on COULD) make him lose his True Alpha status and he would become just a regular Alpha.

After all if Liam and Hayden are by Deaton words free to steal Scott power, while other werewolfs are not, then it stands to reason that if Scott for example went insane or lost control and killed Liam or Hayden, or any other werewolf, with the single purpose of stealing the power, it would have its price. After all Scott would've done something that seemingly goes against what a True Alpha has to be. A True Alpha, apparently has to grow on his own. No stealing.

I never said that if Liam had killed Scott he would've become a True Alpha, because we all know that wouldn't be so. Because that was Theo plan all along. He couldn't steal Scott power, but Liam apparently could. If Liam had killed Scott and taken his power, he'd become simply an Alpha, and then Theo could easily kill Liam and take the Alpha power for himself.