Board Thread:WARNING ALL USERS False Info\Spoilers/@comment-11533671-20130903230528/@comment-6207588-20130904001517

As long as the hunters who shot Talia with the arrow were sticking to the code it would work...if they were hunters like Gerard they may have just been wanting to kill werewolves.

I do believe there is more to Peter's story that we haven't heard about and I agree that he probably killed someone before Derek...more than likely a girlfriend (the comment about the girl always finding out because the teeth and claws come out made we think that maybe something went wrong with his girlfriend).

For some reason I kind of doubt that Talia had blue eyes...not that I necessarily think she is as pure as they have made her out to be thus far (especially if she had Peter do her dirty work so she could keep her hands clean). I just think that Derek wouldn't have been so distressed about his eye color if Talia's had also been blue...I think his comment to her would have maybe been about Paige instead.

I do think that there may be something special about the Hale family line. If they did descend directly from Lycaon or his sons it might explain the reason Talia would not turn Paige...perhaps she felt that werewolves that were turned were not as pure as werewolves that were born. There may have even been other "houses" that had werewolves that were descended from the original werewolves and marriages occured between the houses to keep the lines more pure (the royalty thing). The reason I say this is that of all the packs that were in Beacon Hills, Talia's was the only one that was made up family members. Even the sheriff told Ennis he couldn't see his beta's body because he wasn't family.

If Peter was indeed at that time in a rivalry with Derek for who would eventually be chosen Alpha as some have theorized then perhaps in Peter's mind he thought that turning Paige into a werewolf would cement Paige and Derek's relationship and put a wedge between him and his mother because he chose someone that was not natural born and not from one of the other houses. And this is all just total speculation but you've given a lot of food for thought with your post.