Board Thread:WARNING ALL USERS False Info\Spoilers/@comment-24565701-20140221023529/@comment-24447558-20140222220825

But literally nothing about this argument makes sense... Scott wouldn't have had athsma if he were a born werewolf. We would have felt the pull of the moon even IF Talia removed the memories from him (which I sincerely doubt she would have).

And all of this really just plays into the fact that we, as a fandom, are having a very difficult time with the over-used "Chosen One" trope. 'Chosen Ones' are boring. They rise to power by fate, not hard work, dedication, struggle, perseverance. After everything he's been through, Derek deserves it way more than Scott has based on what we've seen of the characters so far.

Derek allowed for the living shit to get beaten out of him on numerous times to save those he loved. He endured loss after loss after loss and even sacrificed himself to save Scott. Everything that's happening to Scott is being done in the periphery... Scott isn't working for any of it. This is why I have a fault with him as a character. The only time he's ever actively done ANYTHING was the complete out-of-the-blue switch-a-roo that happened in the 2nd season, and even then, he compromised Derek's autonomy to do it, forcing Derek to bite Gerard. Personally, I'd make the argument that Scott is one of the best villains on the series because nobody even realizes it.