Board Thread:False Info and Speculative Discussion/@comment-192.230.165.112-20140420035210/@comment-40.132.218.253-20140618013457

You simply can't let go of your interpretation of the scene. It's not universal. If it were then I'd be agreeing with you and this discussion would've ended ages ago.

Now you're supplying Scott with intent because of something he DIDN'T say? That would be laughed out of court. "Why did you say it that way? You should have said it this way!" Silly in the extreme.

You are welcome to your opinion of the writing, both on the show and my own, but you should stop expecting the world to be a reflection of what's in your head - that's a surefire path to constant disappointment.