Board Thread:False Info and Speculative Discussion/@comment-67.162.31.47-20140715100605/@comment-13965604-20140715173335

BoricuaWolf wrote: LadyX wrote: Do we know if Gerard knows Peter is alive? Gerard is definitely a reasonable hypothesis to me. He 'doesn't know' Kate's alive, which I still have my doubts about, so she wouldn't be on the list. Also, we know they're hypocrits already, Kate not doing the 'honorable' thing by killing herself, and Gerard trying to Turn when he was dying. It wouldn't surprise me in the slightest that he would overlook her little affliction because it could benefit him.

Peter just doesn't make sense to me, and I think he was on the list, and arts dept just wasn't accurate. Mute told him 'don't worry Peter, Derek is next.' So unless he went after Peter as a personal vengeance while working in his hit list it wouldn't be sensible to kill Peter if he wasn't on the list. He didn't kill Scott when he had the chance, and we know he's in the list

Peter's not on the list. We saw the list, and I think this will be confirmed next week. I don't think the Mutes comment implied that Peter was or was not on the list. Like you said the only thing he was saying was that he was there for Derek NOT Peter at that time.

We don't know yet if the fact that Peter is off the list means that the Benefactor doesn't know he's alive. He could be left off for some other unkown reaon.

I'm guessin Kate is not on it, because she's working for the Benefactor since she lead him to the Vault (knowingly or unkowingly).

We shall see.

That's kind of my point, I know we didn't see him on the list. I specifically said I think it could be an arts department oversight. If Peter was not on the list, what purpose would Mute have had to try and kill him? Scott was on the list, and he didn't kill him when he had the opportunity. There had to be a reason he attacked Peter, he and Derek aren't that similar that it was an accident, and Mute certainly didn't seem too beat up over that 'mistake'