Board Thread:False Info and Speculative Discussion/@comment-2245905-20140610223340/@comment-14168656-20140806195141

Bennett89 wrote: Well she took Peter's memory but did she take Mr. Tates bc if not then Malia is proof that his wife cheated (unless Malia's birth mom wasn't ms tate) also its possible he has been lurking around BH. Plus Danny proved that any1 could know about the Supes of BH

Well there are a lot of possibilities:

If Mrs. Tate was Malia's birth mother, it could be from before Mr. Tate & her met and of course Mr. Tate would have known that she was not his daughter all along, but since she dissappeared at such a young age they realistically would not have told her before the accident.

OR Mrs. Tate cheated and he simply did not find out (Prior to her coming home in 3B that is).

Otherwise Malia could be adopted in which case he also would know that he's not her birth father, but again they would not have told her that at such a young age.