Board Thread:False Info and Speculative Discussion/@comment-24919817-20150721161503/@comment-25211211-20150805165526

Mgc26133 wrote: well it was just an example :) Hand size matters, becaue a smaller hand, like 8 year old Malia's, would have to have smaller clawmarks. Scott was barely able to match his to the one on the car, so it must have been an adult.

I believe this is what JEK wanted to say. I think that the hand size doesn't matter, the claw marks could be like meters apart and they still would have been made by the little 8 year old Malia. Theres no way the writers thought that much about it, maybe this DW shooting at the car thing is completely new and they were gonna go with Malia just loosing it and killing her family.