Board Thread:False Info and Speculative Discussion/@comment-78.0.215.197-20150202084809/@comment-4091815-20150304030649

Grahamburglar wrote: Paul.rea wrote:

Grahamburglar wrote: Oh, that makes sense, absolutely. I'm not suggesting Laura Hale should have come back, or that random Omega. But Ennis? Kali? Did the Argents go into the Hale house and cut all the dead wolves in half? (They could have, I suppose!) What about Boyd, Aiden or Erica? Is this a loophole that could be used to bring anybody back from the dead, or was there something about the manner of their deaths that prevents them from coming back?

See, even when there's answers, there's no answers. :P From the bits we saw during the "retrieving Talia's claws" scenes - canonically, we're led to believe that there was nothing left of the Hales who died in the fire. She was reduced to nothing but claws. Those that escaped complete destruction managed to heal. I think you're forgetting that a number of burned bodies were found in the house (according to the report on the fire). Obviously something was left. The report is a prop - which makes it dubious as far as canon is concerned. But even taking that as gospel - it pre-dates the later, more detailed, information we're given about Talia's remains which supersedes the earlier canon. Even if there was nothing left but charred bones, the report would call it a body.