Board Thread:WARNING ALL USERS False Info\Spoilers/@comment-37.24.148.3-20130801173359/@comment-14168656-20130802191847

Jestermonkey4u wrote:

I think most people are forgetting about the Hunter's code. Gerard is the only one that  doesn't follow this but basically the Hunters do NOT hunt or go after the werewolves UNLESS there has been a werewolf killing. Deucalion isn't being hunted and has given no indication that he was involved with the Argents at all, prefering NOT to entice them. The hunters in the episode that almost had Derek were out hunting Ennis because of his Beta killing someone. Also, Deucalion is very wary of the Argent's so I doubt he would have bitten one knowing that they are a family of hunters. The Hunter's Code is also another reason why I place Alex's bite as a revenge one. There was absolutely NO other reason for Deucalion to attack anyone and again, he wasn't being hunted or sought after.

As for Deaton, you already said it. Derek and Paige's story happen at the time of the Alphas, Betas and Talia meet to discuss Ennis' vengeance. (How do we know this? Based on the above argument about WHEN Deucalion bites Alex). Later, we see Talia, Deucalion and Deaton talking about Deucalion meeting with Gerard for peace. All of these things are happening in the same timeframe. Therefore, Deaton must have some power that ages him slower than humans or something similar. Again I'm not saying your wrong. But the logic isn't absolute. The code prevents them from Killing wolves that haven't killed a human. Not hunting them. It is possible that they hunted Deuc. Not saying that I'm sure they did, but nothing is to say it's impossible. Plus Gerard isn't the only person who violates the code. Victoria Argent broke the code (she tried to kill Scott who had never killed anyone). We don't know anything about Alexander Argent. Maybe he stuck by the code; maybe he didn't. We don't know the point is that a million things could have happened to explain how Deuc could have bit him. Also keep in mind at the time of the story Deuc was very good, but unless he too was a "True Alpha" he had to kill someone to become an Alpha himself. People are more complex than just simple good an evil. There are limitless possibilites for the reasons he could have bit Alexander. In addition to that, we don't even know if he really did do it anyway. There's also the possibility that Gerard lied about it (we know he lies that for a fact so pathelogical that his heart doesn't even change beat). And before he got his eyes gouged out Deuc was not weary of the Argents. Thalia and Deaton were. Rewatch the episode. He wasn't worried. They had to caution him.

And your reading the connection between the Alpha Meeting and Paige all wrong. I said that those two events had to be at the same time because they SAID so in the episode. Someone asked Ennice to bite Paige because all the Alphas were there to talk to Thalia and he had just lost one of his pack. That part is stated explicitely. So my acknowledging that doesn't mean anything. There is ABSOLUTELY NO EXPLICIT reference to Alexander in the episode. Where are you getting that Alexander's suicide links the two. The episode links it, nothing else. I understand why you're saying that you think Alpha Meeting and Paige's death happend before the suicide. But whether it was before or after, the Alpha Meeting and Paige's death still happend together and the proof of that has nothing to do with Alexander. I think it's a good theory that you have. You may be right, but it is NOT PROVEN.

The problem with the Deaton thing is that they also said spefically that all of the events occured in Beacon Hills. The meeting between Deaton Thalia and Deuc happened in his clinic. Even if Druids age slowly it would NOT be possible for Deaton to spend 40 years in the same town without ageing be a 60 or 70 year old guy that looks like he's in his mid 40s and it go unoticed. If your theory is right (and it could be), the that is a MAJOR continuity error on the part of the writers.

There are also  two more errors on their part that I forgot to mention the first time:

1) They made sure that the clothing in the Motel California scenes with Alexander match the time period (70s) with regards to the cars and his hair/clothes. In Visionary that was NOT 70s fashion. No way.

2) Cora stated explicitly that in normal human years she's 17. If your theory were true then it wouldn't make sense that she said Derek wasn't dark and broody when she knew him, because he would have become this way 20 YEARS before she was even born. She could not possibly have known what would be a minimun 51 year old Derek before '77.

Another plosible answer: Deaton is really in his 40s, The close actually matched the year it was: 2003, and Cora didn't see or know about all of this because when she was 7 she went to Brasil and missed Derek's change.