Board Thread:False Info and Speculative Discussion/@comment-4723271-20161207204553/@comment-4091815-20161210052401

Clarified thanks. With the card, it was gone. Corey was the only one who could see it until he made it visible to the rest of the world meaning it was masked by whatever masks the riders from those not marked. We have to eliminate the card from the discussion because it was gone and brought back.

The bracelet was made by Gwen, wasn't it? The fact that she gave it to her sister doesn't change the fact that Gwen made it and it existed prior to being gifted to someone now erased.

As for the Jeep, we don't know that the story is made up. The Jeep may well have been stolen and then recovered, again this is all around the time that Stiles was born so his existence could change the outcome of the story considerably.

The biggest reason these new details don't bother me is because Claudia is the one telling the story. She's currently on my "untrustworthy narrator" list. I'm just waiting for the other shoe to drop.

I don't think there's a basis to claim inconsistency in the central premise of the riders based on what we've seen. There is logic to the story within what they've explained so far.