Board Thread:False Info and Speculative Discussion/@comment-207.254.224.12-20140717193212/@comment-4723271-20140721003334

LadyX wrote:

99.170.226.119 wrote:

99.170.226.119 wrote:

LadyX wrote: I'm going to repeat myself. Derek is not seen as a regular Alpha either. Everyone talked about what a shitty Alpha he was when he was one. Comparing Derek and Scott to each other is comparing two SUCKY Alphas. Peter is the only non-sucky alpha without Beta juice to compare to, but there are no similar circumstances by which to compare with. Thus, we have only what was said by more experienced characters. The twins, and Kincaid. Paul, himself, pretty much agreed with this. Paul is only arguing that from what we've seen on screen, he is average, not that he is actually average. Peter lost control & became a beast. The only thing he sowed that made him better than Derek & Scott was that he knew how to use the unique abilities the alphas have. I still don't remember the twins saying he was weak. Still isn't that basically the same thing?

Name: Sean I meant showed

Name: Sean That he 'lost control' is a personal opinion of his actions. He may have told us he 'lost control,' I can't remember, but if he did he can't be trusted. He's a lying, conniving, backstabbing asshole that knows how to be convincing. A sociopath. If he was as insane, and out of control as he wants us to think he wouldn't have been able to plan and execute the plan that he did, nor would he have been able to control only killing people involved in the fire.

You seem to think that everything has to be said verbatim on screen, but it doesn't. We are intelligent human beings who should be able to gather things from what we hear and see on screen. The twins didn't have to say the words weak. We are to gather that the two experienced werewolves think that Scott is weak based on their actions. They thought Scott could take them on if he would let go a little but he either can't, or won't. Either way, it makes him weak. Either by actually being incapable of it, which is flat out weak, or because he won't, meaning he is choosing to be weak. Peter was lying when he said that he had no control, we dicovered that back in season 1, They figured out that Peter lured laura back to town. He did it by carving the spiral into the deer knowing it would bring her back and then he killed her and became alpha, I think it was scott who told derek about what peter did which eventually lead to that big fight between at the hale house.

As I was typing this I realized something, how did peter know that Laura was an alpha? The only way he could possibly know that is if it was passed down to Laura from Talia eventhough its never been confirmed that a werewolf can become an alpha by being next in line for it, I dont see how else he would know if he was in hospital for all those years