Board Thread:WARNING ALL USERS False Info\Spoilers/@comment-174.76.131.202-20131016160725/@comment-11565898-20131019040938

Are we talking in the sense of actual fighting or Fangirl fighting?

If you're discussinf actaul fighting, I'd have to go with Jacob based on the lack of fighting ability on Derek's side. Everytime he gets into a fight he manages to get his ass handed to him. Plus their fight would be simlar to Derek fightin Scott because Jacob, in a sense, is a True Alpha just like Scott.

If you're talking about a fangirl battle then I'd have to go with Derek based on the fact that the show has turned his chracter into a lonely and sensitive werewold while Jacob who is also sensitive has found his partner for life. Meaning people who like the single Jacob now want the single Derek. Plus you find yourself rooting more for Derek because he lost basically everything to something that happened to him while Jacob's only problem throughout the Twilight series was that Bella didn't love him enough to leave Edward.

No offense to anyone who is a fan of both, I just stated my opinion and I love both series equally.