Board Thread:False Info and Speculative Discussion/@comment-25222572-20150805153239/@comment-9630977-20150806123105

I think it is a subjective thing, if the werewolf feels like the person they are killing is innocent their eyes will turn blue and guilt is irrelevant.

With how much a sociopath Peter is, it's almost certain he killed an innocent that he knew was innocent, he just proably didn't care.