Board Thread:WARNING ALL USERS False Info\Spoilers/@comment-11254783-20130730030800/@comment-69.114.214.100-20130731095546

Mexiamerican55 wrote: It's unlikely. Stilinski mentioned it happened a FEW years back. Plus, if it was Paige and she didn't die, then how did Derek's eyes turn blue? He KILLED her, that's why. Jennifer is not Paige. Considering I called Blake in the beginning, I'm also going to call that Paige is NOT Jennifer it doesn't matter if he actually killed her or not, the fact is that Derek THOUGHT that he killed her and that's why his eyes turned blue. Also even if she really was dead, she coulda just came back to life somehow. But I o see your point about too many coincidences.

She could be one of the other alphas emiserries who was killed (like Ethan said) and she's back for revenge or she could have just been a random target or something.