Board Thread:False Info and Speculative Discussion/@comment-131.118.255.194-20150707203835/@comment-26601629-20150803035919

LadyX wrote:

Jestermonkey4u wrote: You can't seriously apply real world medicine here. Who says the Dread Doctor's didn't remove the old kidney?

The bottom line is that there are probably half a dozen ways the writers could explain it. Do we really need it spelled out in the show? Yes, yes I do, and I need it to make sense or the show has completely lost me for the season if she's to play any sort of role more than another episode or two. He can ask me to believe the impossible, but not the improbable. He's already stretching that with having her in soccer since there's no way she would be doing that. Neither the school or her doctors would condone it. My school wouldn't even let me participate in the soccer segment in gym when I went, or the volleyball segment amongst others because the school didn't want to be held liable if something happened. The transplanted kidney isn't protected by anything more than your own layer of fat because it's placed on top of your lower abs on one side.

TLDR: yes, I need an explanation that shows he thought about this throughly because he's already made mistakes with her athletics. Wow, you seem to be taking this issue a little to personally or seeriously.

Anyways, was there ever a definite date mentioned?

For all we know she could have had the surgery a few weeks or a few years. Or are you saying that people who have transplants can never again participate in strenious activites. Cause I know a football player who had one with the heart and still kept on playing for several years.

The whole foreign body thing though, maybe you have a point, or maybe it's explainable(I'm pretty sure we'll never know) but, it's sure that their physiology changes when they turn. Isn't it possible that the physiology changed just enough for the body to recognize the new organ as local, Smallville and Tokyo Ghoul anyone?