Board Thread:WARNING ALL USERS False Info\Spoilers/@comment-72.192.213.236-20130730235408/@comment-11533671-20130801182012

Charinfox wrote: After rewatching the flashback episode, I'm thinking that it wasn't Derek's story that Peter was telling, it was his own. Here's why

Remember in Season 2, when teenage Peter was tricking Lydia and there was a close up of him when he was in high school. He was a basket ball star. I thought at first that this was something they did as a family thing, but in the flashback episode, they kept going back to basketball. For example, when "Derek" met Paige, he was playing basketball in the hallway and when Paige was being turned, "Derek" was messing around with a basketball.

Also when Peter was telling the story, he kept talking about how "Derek" might think that it was all his idea(which it was) and that if he remembered Ennis, he wasn't letting on. Derek would have to have known Ennis because his mom was the Alpha, so they would have met at some point.

Finally, when Peter was telling the story, he didn't look like he was talking about his nephew; it looked like it was more personal than that.

I know these don't seem like good enough reasons, but I honestly think that Peter was telling his own story and that Derek may have had something to do with Paige's disaperance into the woods(like he helped make it look like an animal attack), but I dont think that it was his story that Peter was telling. I think you have it. I thought the exact same thing right after Stiles mentioned that Peter was an unreliable narrarator. I immediately thought that the truth lay in Peter and Derek's roles being switched. As for Derek's eyes being blue, this is a recent development. They weren't blue in season 1 or 2. I think they turned blue because of Boyd's death. He took an innocent life, regardless of that life being a werewolves or not, because Boyd never killed anyone he was an innocent person stll.