Board Thread:False Info and Speculative Discussion/@comment-11533671-20140912050918/@comment-25222572-20140912173823

Mgc26133 wrote: He also killed the 2 thugs that picked on Stiles and Scott when they were out to get drunk.

He attacked that guy in bus. I can't tell whether he couldn't or didn't kill him, but he died anyway.

His nurse.

He forced Scott to transform and kill all of his friends.

oh and.. the janitor..

Biting Lydia, killing Kate..

Maybe some were responsible of what happened to him, but some cannot be justified.

I also like Peter, but from an objective point of view, he really is evil. The 2 thugs were literally the ones who doused his home in gasoline.

The bus driver used to be in insurance, the reason he was working there was that he was terminated from his old postion over suspicion of fraud (in regards to the Hale Fire, presumably).

His nurse was a psychopath who was perfectly alright with helping him kill people. We were given no reason for this assistance, she had none of Peter's justifications or excuses. She just........wanted peeps to die, I guess? The fact that Peter killed her may be seen as a public service in that regard..........though, yes, he had no personal justification for kiling her, other than a cynical, "clean up loose ends" kind of mind frame.

That doesn't count for anything? No one died?

The janitor is quite possibly the only innocent victim in the entire 1st season, as I cannot recall off-hand whether or not he was connected with the Hale Fire (if anyone rememberrs, do let me know).

Biting Lydia served a purpose. He never intended for her to die, just to become his "back up plan" if all else failed.

And Kate? She was/is a sadistic murderer of men, wolves, women and puppies! She gets off on torturing what, in her words, were nothing but "dumb animals"! She murdered his entire family, and forced him to suffer horribly with literally no jusification or provocation! She is the only person in the entire season who just about everyone would agree, DESERVED to pay for her actions.

And from an objective point of view, evil is in and of itself not a valid form of classification for a person. Or anything else really. Neither is "good".