Board Thread:False Info and Speculative Discussion/@comment-4091815-20140701192156/@comment-13965604-20140714145046

Grahamburglar wrote: I'm not a writer -- I'm an actor, so, yeah, I can tell when a script is well written or makes sense. It's, y'know, part of my job. Besides, you do know that when a writer writes something it's for the consumption of an audience, yes? Which means it should make sense to audience, shouldn't leave them with too many questions, etc?

But it IS clear that Kate knew Derek was a werewolf and that Derek knew Kate knew he was a werewolf. That is clear. Unquestionably. Go rewatch the episode if you have ANY doubt of that. And then stop doubting it because you're absolutely wrong.

Now, to say that she knows he's a werewolf but hasn't seen his eyes doesn't make much sense either. He just told her? Didn't show her anything? Or are you going to trying telling me he shifted but without changing his eyes? Because then I would take the opportunity to remind you how little control he had at that point in his life.

There's any number of ways or reasons that he revealed his lycanthropy to Kate and I'm not even beginning to speculate on that. All I'm saying is there's not a way for Kate not to have seen his eyes before the fire where what happened in "117" makes sense.

As a side note: how can you possibly enjoy this show with as many blanks as it constantly leaves open?

An additional note, it's never been shown in canon that they could shift without changing their eye color. We know their eyes can change without the rest of their faces shifting, but it's never been stated/shown to be able to be done in reverse.