Board Thread:WARNING ALL USERS False Info\Spoilers/@comment-11260666-20140107172316/@comment-13965604-20140107194252

It's an interesting theory, and we will have to wait and see, but I don't think he is who has Derek and Peter. His behavior did just seem like a man who lost his family in a tragic accident YEARS ago, and now the police are saying it may have been murder. I think I would act the same way. But the way the dog just stopped barking was super weird, and a little creepy. I would've expected the dog to stop barking but keep growling at the intruder, or whimper a bit and go to the Dad, not just stop and walk away. And so ebody mentioned they thought it was supposed to be comedic relief, but it really wasn't funny at all, so I doubt that's what they were going for. There is definitely more to this dad that we need to see