Board Thread:False Info and Speculative Discussion/@comment-207.254.224.12-20140717193212/@comment-19765459-20140718023627

Paul.rea wrote: Nope you stating things that never happened as if they were fact makes it seem like you've worked it out pretty well in your (allegedly) non-evil mind.

Peter had speed and was pretty sneaky - but he never faced any supernatural in a one on one fight.

So how can we know what would have happened?

I'm beginning to wonder if you are even watching the show! Also, weren't you criticizing me for making insulting statements about other people? You know, seeing as how you have now progressed to calling me "evil"? Remember what I said about hypocrisy and coming down off the moral high horse? You don't belong up there. Especially not when I am commenting on canonical events on a horror-oriented TV show!

You are also outright wrong. Peter curb-stomped Derek in S1E9.

So how can we know what would have happened? Well, we know what has actually been shown (even though you seem to have either never watched it or else forgotten about it). The only thing we haven't seen is Alpha!Peter versus another Alpha. He did fight Voltron Wolf as a Beta, but neither he nor Scott had any more luck against them than anyone else (other than Jennifer) had without using electricity as a weapon. Since they canonically killed their previous Alpha in merged form (before becoming Alphas themselves), it is safe to say that even a regular Alpha was not enough to tackle them.