Board Thread:False Info and Speculative Discussion/@comment-25176701-20150818031151/@comment-25176701-20150818142152

JEK wrote: Wolf Josh wrote: I felt like that it was very selfish of Scott to not forgive him, or give Stiles a chance to explain what happened his way instead of listening to Theo, a kid who comes back after being gone for so long. Also, for not giving her the bite, I believe he should because it might heal her. I think it would and for him not to even try....it's selfish IMO. Honestly, I can't think of a single reason for Scott NOT to give her the Bite, except for the incredibly selfish "But it might kill her, and I don't want to kill anyone!". I mean, come on. She's already dying, what could it hurt? Best case, she recovers. Worst case, it doesn't save her, and she dies like she was already going to.

"sighs"

Where's Peter when you need him, to state the facts of the matter very coldly and calmly? Not that anyone ever listened to him.............

I agree. In my opinion, if Hayden dies because Scott decided to do nothing about it, he would have killed her anyway. If Scott tries to save her, but she dies anyway, I wouldn't blame him for it, since he didn't give up. Somebody watching another person die without helping them is just as bad as killing them yourself. Scott can't say "I didn't kill her" when he just decided not to help her, but let her die instead.