Board Thread:False Info and Speculative Discussion/@comment-2245905-20140610223340/@comment-14168656-20140806220221

EastYorkTeenWolfFan wrote: BoricuaWolf wrote: OmegaWulfgar wrote: Unless Gerard gained the ability of Clairvoyance, It can't be him.

There is absolutely no way Gerard is aware of Kate being alive unless he has contacts in Beacon Hills. Also, if it was indeed the Benefactor that physically stole the bearer ponds, it can't be Gerard. Black liquid is constantly oozing out of every hole in his face which makes it highly inconvenient for him to perform tasks such as a heist.

The thing is that NO-ONE could actually REASONABLY know all of the things the benefactor knows except one person: Peter. Think about it: he knows who all of the supernatural people are, that kate is alive AND supernatural, that Liam got bit, that Kira & her mom are supernatural, the Hale family history, that Malia is really his daughter, the history of the triskaleon/that Kate was having trouble with control so she'd want it, and that the triskaleon and the money was in the vault.

The only thing it wouldn't make sense for Peter to know (going solely off of what we've seen on camera) is that Parrish is supernatural, especially since there's still a chance that Parrish HIMSELF doesn't know. Based on what we as the audiance no NO-ONE should know all of that. So basing our guesses off of who's privy to what information will not work.

Oh and BTW just to be clear, It's NOT I repeat  NOT Peter LOL. Geraurd could very well know everything going on in beacon hills after all we can persume he knew Scott was a werewolf and I don't think it was something Chris shareed with him either eceppsely by the way Chris acted around Scott in the second season heck he even helped him out then

I think people are missing my point a little here. The pont I was trying to make is that ANYONE could know these things if they were supplied with the information, but going based off of ONLY what we know as the audiance from what's been on camera or discussed or could reasonably infer, no-one should know all the things The Benefactor knows. People were trying to pick who was most likely based on what WE as an audiance have seen. IE does Gerard know or not know that Kate is alive and supernatural. I was not arguing against Gerard being the Benefactor. It actually would make a lot of sense. It almost seems TOO easy, which is why I'm guessing it's not him. I don't think it's him, but I was arguing about WHY the other poster didn't think it was him. I was actually arguing against ruling him out based on what knowledge we precieve him to have. All I was saying is based on what we know ONLY, the only person that has been SHOWN TO US to know 90% of this stuff is Peter. But then again I don't think it's Peter either so go figure...