Board Thread:False Info and Speculative Discussion/@comment-24732895-20140731064438/@comment-13965604-20140801235947

RemyObburn wrote: LadyX wrote:

RemyObburn wrote: I doubt it would be deatonconsidering he's already been helping Scott and the gang every season so far so why would be just now decided to whip all the supernaturals out, including them. I know you guys are gonna say "balance" but how is whipping out all the supernaturals balance? it's that just switching one extreme for another? If Deaton wanted to restore balance by way of murder he'd probably systematically take out the excess sup's not rob from the family he was the th emissary or (who have done him no wrong) and hire a bunch of sadistic assassins and eliminate everyone including the one wolf he swore to protect (derek) Maybe it's not human/supernatural, but good /bad being out of balance? Too much good joojoo needs balanced out? Maybe.

Also Deaton has never been terribly helpful or forthcoming If it's a good vs bad joojoo (great word choice by the way lol) type deal then why would he only be going after supernaturals? So far there has not been a single human being on that list. surely there are good supernaturals and bad supernaturals just like their are good and bad human, so why is it that all supernaturals are to be killed despite their good or bad joojoo?

Deaton has been fairly helpful, supplying the moutain ash for scott and stiles, always willing to provide counsel (granted he's not very direct but it still somehow manages to click for the characters when they need it) he helped subdue nogitsune stiles on more than one occassion and even this season he's already saved Brett AND Liam's life, both of whom are on the list

You bring up solid points, but of course he would save them when brought to him, he doesn't want to be caught out early. I do t know, Jeff doesn't always make a ton of sense.

In all honesty, I don't really buy Deaton being this bad guy. But I do think he could easily be made one some season.