Board Thread:False Info and Speculative Discussion/@comment-98.193.9.109-20140722035026/@comment-16072563-20140820211516

Although the whole Phoenix theory sounds good, it doesn't make much sense. JD hasn't reinvented any of the supernatural beings on the show. A banshee, or a wailing woman, is female and he has stayed true to that with Meredith, Lydia and Lydia's grandmother being the only known banshees on the show. A phoenix isn't known as a shapeshifter and is a bird, so that would be inventing a new supernatural being while naming it after one that already exists.