Board Thread:WARNING ALL USERS False Info\Spoilers/@comment-76.7.31.153-20140111210933/@comment-184.153.215.92-20140113013716

Also in Season 1 Stiles says there r no wolves where they live and it does look smaller than a wolf so it has to be a coyote. Also her dad mention having to keep coyotes away. as for it being Malia it makes sense cause the car accident was the night of a full moon, claw marks were on the car, her body disappered and was never found and the creatures eyes were blue meaning it took life. so she had to have transformed in the car, killed her mother and sister and caused the car to crash and ran off and has been in hiding for 8 years. Maybe the Nemeton brought her back to Beacon Hills. thats how I interpret it. Scott most likely pieced it together when he saw the creatures blue eyes.