Board Thread:False Info and Speculative Discussion/@comment-6529205-20140419164329/@comment-162.212.127.190-20140710061048

"It's not the relationship I have issues with. It's that they had sex when neither of them were competent to be making those decisions. They were in a mental institution because Stiles hadn't slept in days (when 16 hours impairs you as much as having a .08 bac) he had been being possessed, and didn't know what was real and fake, and Malia was a child who had been a coyote for half of her life, and turned back in to a person. While sex might be a reasonable activity given her previous life, she wasn't competent to make that decision for anyone either. It was bad, sketchy writing. As is putting her into normal classes because it's more convenient.

We should be able to expect some reasonable logic in the writing. Even in a supernatural show. The best supernatural shows are the ones that make you believe they could be real, and logical writing choices makes that happen." Sorry Lady X, I have no clue how to actually do the quote thing but you just said that Stiles shouldn't be able to make the decision to have sex because he was the equivalent of drunk? Drunk people are very capable of that decision. Plus he wasn't possessed, at the time the Nogitsune was poisoned and wasn't bothering him. Plus Malia was in there more just to deal with the fact she has anger issues and her father probably figured she had issues living in the woods for so long. However, she was obviously mentally competent so the only thing that I agree made the sex weird was that it was in a creepy basement. But hey, people have lost their virginities in weirder. I will agree that it is weird to put her in mainstream classes like that. The only possible explanation I have for that is that the coach was so excited at how athletic she seemed (we see this in the last scene of season 3b) that he was trying to integrate her quickly and get her athletically eligible.