Board Thread:False Info and Speculative Discussion/@comment-4295751-20150811205600/@comment-13965604-20150814131429

Just because she potentially did the clawing to check, doesn't mean she didn't find alive Malia and do the werewolf's normal throat slash to her and think she was dead when she wasn't. That throat slash they always seem so confident about seems to have only worked once (so far) out of how many times it's been used? Three or four times right? They did it with Kate, Braedan, Jennifer, and I think they did that with Peter including burning him, and so far only Jennifer is actually dead. Even if you don't want to include Peter, that's still only 33% effectiveness rate, which could still change in the future.

She could've told ten year old traumatized Malia that it was her fault they had to die, and then slash her throat and leave.