Board Thread:WARNING ALL USERS False Info\Spoilers/@comment-92.238.137.64-20140207010708/@comment-13965604-20140212014439

Grahamburglar wrote: 141.0.8.139 wrote: I think that he isn't Scott's biological father, Scott is really a Hale whose mom had an affair with Talia's husband, and Talia told Derek that Scott is his brother. Is it me or is Derek incredibly kind to Scott lately? In order for this theory to work.... you basically have to ignore everything we know thus far. I'm not saying that's impossible, I'm just saying it's kind of nonsensical. Like, here are the facts thus far:

-Melissa McCall had no idea who Peter Hale was and had never seen him before in Season 1. If she'd known the Hales, you'd think she would have recognized Peter.

-It's Agent McCall's secret. If Melissa McCall had the affair, wouldn't that be *her* secret?

-Scott and Melissa both treat Agent McCall like he's a terrible person because of something that happened before. If Melissa is the one who had an affair, this makes no sense.

Indeed. If anything, Agent McCall might be the Mr.Hale no one knows anything about and had an affair with Melissa. Not that I necessarily believe that theory, but it's the only way I can make the whole 'Derek and Scott are really related' and the McCall is there to talk about parentage' theories work