Board Thread:False Info and Speculative Discussion/@comment-70.126.118.249-20140814234001/@comment-4091815-20140815013050

70.126.118.249 wrote: And you do a fantastic job.... That I will say. ..bb was on amc....tw is my #nuffsaid... One more thing if Kate turned from peters scratch.... Why not Braden from deucalions?.. Why isn't that a bigger flaw then timeline? They covered over that pretty well with "it hardly ever happens." If it's rare then why would it happen twice in one town?

I'm not worried so much about their universe rules - those are expandable and they seldom if ever directly contradict themselves. Wolfsbane always does number on werewolves - if this kind acts differently or is a different color - that's because it's a different species - it's covered.

But simple things like the ages of their characters - well that's something that shouldn't change and you really can't fudge once you clearly stated it.

Malia was 17 when they found her in October (during 3b) - was 9 when she went missing and was gone for 8 years. They had multiple people say those things in multiple episodes. It was the crux of her character and basically the only thing we knew about her.

Now in the same episode they contradicted all that - they remembered correctly that Lydia is turning 18 in March. She was 16 when she went missing in Omega, turned 17 in March during Party Guessed and will turn 18 "in a few weeks."

So in one instance they stick to what they've said before but in another they contradict everything we know about a character.

Incredibly and unnecessarily sloppy.