Talk:Melissa McCall/@comment-5327104-20120731220348/@comment-72.156.214.183-20120731223006

I did not say she WAS def a werewolf. I started that post out with an "IF" in capital letters ti emphasize that it was only a POSSIBILITY to me. Your reasoning is very sound and I'd respect your opinion a hell of lot more if you didn't start out by calling me freaking names.

If Melissa had any knowledge of werewolves (either by her family line or her husband's), then she probably still wouldn't have suspected Scott - here's why. Scott had asthma from the time he was very small, so that would be a dead giveaway that he didn't carry the gene. In the same way Erica's physical problems were healed when she turned, Scott would never have developed asthma if he carried the gene. IF (again, IF) she had any knowledge at all about werewolves, she would've assumed a long time ago that Scott wasn't one and that's why she'd be sooo in denial that night. She didn't scream her head off like a normal person would - she very calmly put her hand over her mouth and kept repeating "no, no, no" like she knew the deal. I think it's safe to say she knows something about what she saw, even if her bloodline had nothing to do with it.