Board Thread:False Info and Speculative Discussion/@comment-201.76.133.29-20140726172901/@comment-11533671-20140728042020

I just don't place that much stock into the other way. Every instance of a druid doing it has shown them only use a handful which is fine for the circle they made. When Scott's mom (human) threw the ash for the barrier against the Oni, not only did it magically land perfectly but again - she used only a handful and yes it looked like enough to cover that area. I think it works regardless of the person throwing it as long as they believe. Sorta like saying the magic words to use a magical ring in D&D, or Tinkerbell's magic is partly due to the belief in fairies.

I admit I thought the same as LadyX, Graham and yourself when I saw it for the first time but then I realized that the way it works is much simpler especially since, as I've said - why would Stiles need a bag of it at all IF it can grow perpetually by thought? Neither belief is 100 % proven, I'll concede to that...but I think my spin more logically fits the scene. At least, imho. Jeff has only said the ash is magic and Stiles is not. Given all of these reasons is why I disagree that the ash expanded via creating more of itself.

Oh and LadyX...all I ever told you was that your belief wasn't canon. You insisted I was wrong. Debating is one thing...given an opinion is one thing...but stating something IS canon if it hasn't been shown is just your opinion vs mine. I can respectfully disagree with your opinion.