Board Thread:COMPLETE BULLSHIT Forum/@comment-24477541-20140325164525/@comment-13965604-20140325192618

Grahamburglar wrote: I think it's more likely to be Malia. After all -- Talia took Peter's memory of the child. I doubt she took everyone's and I'm sure more people knew about her than just him. (Plus, I bet the news about the missing girl was widespread and if the sheriff and the kids can come to the conclusion it was a werewolf, so can hunters.) And why would people think that Talia took Peter's memory of his daughter? They seemed to think Peter knew where the she-wolf was -- if it's his daughter, that makes sense.

Kate may have gone to South America but again, why. And certainly, if these South American hunters knew the Argents (they seem to), enough to hear about Victoria's death, they would definitely have heard Kate was dead and about her funeral. Even if they found out she was alive because Kate went to South America, it's an awful big stretch to then assume that everyone knows that she's alive and where she is -- besides, why not tell Chris about it?

I agree that Kate's probably a red herring for the actual she-wolf, but I really don't think it's Malia. Firstly, I can't see news of a car accident with a missing, presumed eaten, girl would make it all the way from Northern California to South America. Not Mexico, which is still North America. Not Belize, Costa Rica, El Salvador, Guatemala, Honduras, Nicaragua, or Panama, which are Central America. But all the way to, at closest, Columbia or Venezuela. If Derek mentioned a specific country, I apologize, I can't recall it right now. Secondly, Malia has spent the last 8 years of her life as a coyote protecting the accident site. When and why would she travel so far away on her own? Thirdly, the fact that she's a coyote, not a wolf.