Board Thread:False Info and Speculative Discussion/@comment-50.117.41.228-20140326230237/@comment-13965604-20140326234717

There was an interview with Ian where he said that Talia did it to 'protect Malia' well, she never protected her own kids from growing up around Peter. There is no excuse for taking the memories of his child away from him, unless it was after the accident, and he was hurting so bad that she thought it would be a mercy to just forget. We have no idea what kind of father he would've been. My dad was a controlling abusive asshat to my mom, but he was great with me until I started high school and wanted to do my own thing.

If he asked her to take them, don't you think he would remember that, and think 'hey, I must've had a good reason for that'?