Board Thread:False Info and Speculative Discussion/@comment-78.0.215.197-20150202084809/@comment-6383956-20150302192123

3) You're absolutely making an assumption there -- a good one, sure. But we do not have the confirmation that she was dead that we have for Peter. And, if you are correct, that opens a whole tangle of other questions -- if werewolves continue to heal even after death how do they ever die? Why didn't Talia come back to life or any of the other wolves in the Hale house? What about Ennis? Or Kali?

2) If it's the contact, not the grabber, find me any evidence of that whatsoever. Any. Seriously, you keep saying that but there's nothing supporting that theory. Nothing.

2a) Cora got hit in the head with a weight. Literally, that's the wound. That's the wound that apparently renders werewolves incapable of healing even though they can heal from beyond death (according to you). Healing Cora of that wound (which, in real life, there's a really solid chance that would not have killed an ordinary person and they would have recovered after a long long long time) sapped Derek's Alpha spark. And that's the only instance we have in canon of a werewolf healing someone else's wounds -- rather than just sapping away the pain. And it took away the Alpha spark. From what Peter said about it, it sounded like healing someone does that, doesn't matter what kind of wound. Unless, again, you have any evidence you've for whatever reason failed to bring to the table over the course of this entire thread.

1) Oh, because the bank vault was just lined wall to wall with windows? The fact that the vault was made out of a specific material is pretty clearly telling us that there is more than "direct moonlight" creating the boost. It may be more powerful if it is direct, but it seems clear that without the hecatolite the Alpha pack wouldn't have been able to deprive its captives of moonlight. Otherwise, they could have just been kept in an ordinary bank vault and the whole hecatolite thing wouldn't have been relevant and probably wouldn't have been brought up to begin with.

4) You've got me there -- although it's still very different from what happened to Lydia. Given that Peter was alive at the time. And also, Peter was Scott's Alpha and we've seen that Alphas  have pull over their pack (and even just other shapeshifters to an extent.) Scott also didn't see hallucinations of Peter to make him do that.

You might be right -- as I've said before -- but there's enough gaps in the information provided by canon that you can't say for sure that you are. You're positing a theory and calling it canon, which you don't let anybody else on this Wiki get away with.