Talk:Allison Argent/@comment-67.238.136.211-20120901162848/@comment-4802762-20120909163335

Derek tried to kill Lydia because all signs pointed to her as the Kanima. The Kanima is the result of a werewolf bite gone wrong; he knows that Lydia was bitten but didn't turn and went completely crazy. I don't know about you but I'd classify that as "gone completely wrong". Plus, he only wanted to kill Lydia. Allison not only tried to kill Derek but Isaac, Scott, Erica and Boyd (all people who had nothing to do with her mother's suicide). Allison went against her instincts (which is the dumbest decision a hunter can make) and trusted a man who she knew she couldn't trust from the beginning. Allison trusting Gerard led to her almost dying; Derek trusting Peter led to multiple lives being saved. We don't know if Derek will trust Peter after all of this. It could have been a one time thing. And Allison had a father right downstairs that she could have gone to for answers and comfort but instead goes to the "not so right" grandfather that she's never trusted.