Board Thread:False Info and Speculative Discussion/@comment-24.130.28.230-20150721180826/@comment-4091815-20160202005555

Are you discussing the information provided in the forums? In that case, yes. I stated quite clearly that Banshee are not supernatural in the canon as it stands currently. This is a fact of the canon. There may be another explaination but none has been provided by the show so, as of this minute, it is canon.

The latest canon is that nothing supernatural can cross mountain ash.

The article hedges that slightly, as we do in most articles, that they appear to be non-supernatural because canon on a currently airing show is apt to change or get retconned so we keep to observable facts.

You can disagree all you like. I don't mind and don't even take issue with the alternate explanations that have been put forward. But, as of right now, the canon is that nothing supernatural can cross a mountain ash barrier. That would cover Banshee although they've not been specifically mentioned.

I've also said a few times, even though you chose not to quote it here, that the canon can, (and often does) change as new information is provided. In this case the dialogue was quite specific and mentioned in two different episodes. This is a piece of information the writers want us to have and we've applied it to our articles.