Board Thread:False Info and Speculative Discussion/@comment-25176701-20150818031151/@comment-13965604-20150823160125

Stiles deserves (from Scott's perspective) the benefit of doubting Theo's word on what happened. Enough to actually ask what happened, instead of "why did you do it" That whole scene was set up in a manner that Scott thought he knew what happened, and really didn't want to hear Stiles response, in my opinion. He wanted Stiles to say "no, I didn't do it" which isn't the same thing.