Board Thread:WARNING ALL USERS False Info\Spoilers/@comment-37.24.148.3-20130801173359/@comment-13899768-20130803173052

Jestermonkey4u wrote: Still not done with my newer timeline but in the meantime, I came across a couple of sites that really intrigued me and I can't find a single real flaw in what they say. I've included the link to one of these that I felt best established the points. If anyone has any corrections please feel free to let me know. Thanks! Sorry it's so long!

http://uniwolfwerecorn.tumblr.com/post/56555724414/visionary-dereks-part-in-peters-narrative

The theory is that the events in Peter’s narrative did not actually happen to Derek, but to Peter himself. That it was Peter who fell in love with Paige, dated her, arranged for her to be bitten, and killed her – that it happened when Peter went to high school, and not Derek.

The article does a much better job at explaning what I'm about to reveal but I will give just a few key points that I think really stood out as significant.

1) Peter was a basketball player, with a trophy and everything in the case at school.

2) The plaid shirt that Derek is seen wearing is exactly like the shirt Peter has on in Abomination when Lydia sees him outside the counselor’s office.

3. Age discrepancies  (With minimal changes, this one is a copy/paste from the link)

In the flashbacks in season two that shows Peter during the fire at the Hale house, Peter is played by Ian Bohen. In the flashbacks in Visionary, with the events taking place one year before the fire, he is played by Michael Fjordbak, who looks barely older than Young Derek Ian Nelson. Why?

There is absolutely no reason to chose Michael Fjordbak instead of Ian Bohen, if it really is Derek’s story and not Peter’s.

4) Paige's clothing (waist-high jeans and boots) and the haircut of Derek's black friend (Will Smith from early Fresh Prince of Bel-air/ Kid-n-Play style) are from the late 80's/ early 90's, NOT 2004.

5) THIS IS ANOTHER COPY/PASTE FROM THE LINK:

Peter tells us Derek is fifteen years old and a sophomore at the time he meets Paige. Kate burned the Hale house down in 2005 - six years before the show started in 2011.

According to Derek’s ID, he was born in 1988, and would have been sixteen in 2005 (turning seventeen in November). Even if he was, in fact, older than that, his official date of birth would still have been in 1988, making him a high school student at that time.

Since Derek very likely only went to Beacon Hills High once in his life, that means that there was one year between Paige’s death (and his eyes turning blue) and Derek sleeping with Kate.

The link I've provided has many other pretty significant points that do a much better job then this post could do including delving more into Kate Argent/Derek relationship, Cora and her memory, Derek not remembering Ennis, etc. I urge anyone interested to check it out for yourselves and please let me know your input. Wow. I mean, I took this into consideration before and just dismissed it as Peter being creepy as all hell. But now that I actually read what I was trying to put together in my head. It's fantastic and makes sense in my head.