Board Thread:Legitimate Canon Questions/@comment-141.224.199.87-20140730014502/@comment-11533671-20140809214722

I completely agree that the Mute "thing" certainly needs an explanation no matter how this ends up.

There is a reason that most of us have a list of suspects and not a singular Prime one; no matter who you suspect there exists reasons for AND against their inclusion.

I figured the Mute was staking out Dereks loft and mistook Peter for Derek initially (How was he to know that Peter would enter b4 Derek?) - not saying this is true, only a possibility.

Since Peter isn't on the list...a mistake like that seems reasonable as to why he was tomahawked. Really though, until we are given the answers, that scene with all of its how's/why's and ?'s will remain only speculation.