Board Thread:False Info and Speculative Discussion/@comment-128.163.7.156-20140915023057/@comment-5285305-20140916182357

You are correct. In Season 3 Episode 10, she told the rest of the gang why Deucalion wouldn't hurt Scott's mom: because he wants the rarest of Alphas in his ranks. Peter then says "True Alpha" followed by "Our little Scott". And in the finale while attempting to go through the mountain ash surrounding Jennifer, his eyes turn from yellow to Red officially. Jennifer asks "How did you do that?" he responds with "I'm an Alpha now."

Jennifer knew he was a True Alpha.

I have to rewatch the Season 4 finale and catch the part where Peter says that you can't take a True Alpha's power, because I don't recall that. With the previous info in mind, I'm thinking he lied to remove any potential suspicions towards him betraying Scott & Co. Anyone with a half brain would be on their toes while keeping a former Alpha with killing tendecnies around, and he knows that. As for the knife situation, we don't know what that knife would have done to Scott because we haven't seen it be used against the Berserkers. Therefore, its not right to conclude that it would've killed him. It was most likely meant to injure him enough to keep him down so Peter could land the final blow.