Board Thread:False Info and Speculative Discussion/@comment-25176701-20150818031151/@comment-13965604-20150820040903

AlphaOfAlphas wrote: T Angelus Ballack wrote: But the problem is how unrealistic all this is, Malia literally shared everything with Stiles, until she suddenly decided not to for apparently no reason at all. She just decided one day, No i'm not gonna share this.

The scene with stiles and scott was also unrealistic, I get that they were trying to show the pack drifting apart by creating a wedge between between the 2 core members, but the dialogue was just strange.

Scott seems pissed that Stiles killed someone

Stiles explains he was going to kill my dad ( why not just straight up say what it was, an accident)

he never wanted donovan at the moment it happened, but he doesn't once mention this, eventually the conversation reaches the point of self defence

Scott has been told that Stiles kept bashing donovan until his skull caved in, and stiles says self-defence, but scott never once mentions that stiles went too far for self defence.

Like if you've been told your friend that you know bashed someone's head in repetedly, and you confront them, and ask why did you do it, and they say self-defense, wouldn't the natural thing be to say something like you went too far for self defense, or why didn't you hit him once, or why did you keep hitting him., Then the friend will explain what really happened.

But the tried to evade stiles telling scott it was an accident, even though it was

They stopped scott from mentioning how grueseome the death was even though it was for self defense, so that stiles doesn't expose the ruse.

The whole thing just felt off, If they didn't plan it to fool Theo, then the writers have used the most stupid form of miscommunication ever, where they are talking to each other but aren't saying anything. I think Scott said something like "But not like that! At that point, it's not self defense anymore".

But yeah, I don't get why Stiles wouldn't just come clean and explain what happened. All Scott had was the wrench, yet Stiles automatically assumed that Scott knew exactly what happened.

I LOLed so hard when Scott was like "Why didn't you tell me?" and Stiles said "...I couldn't" in such a sheepish voice. An innocent man couldn't have sounded any more guilty LOL.

Also, I don't get why Scott didn't believe Stiles when Stiles kept on asking him if he did. Couldn't Scott just listen to his heart beat and tell that Stiles was telling the truth? It worked so many times in other seasons.

Heck, couldn't he just listen to Theo's heart beat when he was talking all that bullsh*t? I mean, how many acting classes did Theo go to until it seemed like even he believes his lies? Maybe that's why he was gone for so long...

I seem to recall that they made a point to show us that Stiles can lie to werewolves, we just don't know who all has figured that out yet.

As for Theo. people on the antisocial personality spectrum can very easily lie without giving any tells. If you have no morals what even is lying?