Board Thread:False Info and Speculative Discussion/@comment-24732895-20140622230817/@comment-11533671-20140627040907

You mentioning Allison and the conversation about it being Stiles has no bearing on whether or not he had enough ash to complete the job and that scene...it is just diverting away from the debate because Allison doing it or not is irrelevant since she didn't do it and I wasn't debating if Stiles had to do it or not. The characters in the episode said he had to, not me.

As for the scene itself: You are misinterpreting the conversation to fit your ideas. That is fan fiction. Actually, you are doing exactly what you lay claim I and bible thumping Christians do, losing the context of the entire sentence.

When he says  "...with a handful of magic fairy dust", it is because he has a handful of ash in his hand when he calls! Not that he only has a handful of ash left. He stated he has "like 50 ft. of ash left, and I'm out." He doesn't state, 'All I have left is 50 ft. to cover and I only have a handful of magic fairy dust' nor does he say '...I still have 50 ft. of ground to cover but I'm out of ash' (which is what I think most people would say if that was the case). That is a big difference. He says he has about 50 ft. of ash''. ''Fifty feet of ash is different than saying fifty feet of ground.

You can't validate something by saying that you felt it was an idea the writers were toying with. That is exactly what leads to fan fiction. I've only pointed out what was seen and heard via the episode not what others think, feel, have heard from non canon sources or whatever the case may be. You insist on your version of events but admit  "...it's not canon."

"I don't know why you insist on arguing over the fact that I feel...". Why do I insist? Because this site is dedicated to canonical truths and not speculation. Someone could actually begin believing that Stiles is a magician or supernatural creature all because you "felt" or thought the writers were going to give some magical powers to Stiles and have some ash magically expand to cover the distance. That is not what they scrapped for S2. They scrapped Jackson's backstory.

I agree to leave it at that and please don't take this as a personal attack or any such thing, I was just pointing out the fallacy of the magic ash expansion theory.