Board Thread:False Info and Speculative Discussion/@comment-24732895-20150630102249/@comment-4091815-20150705175437

Grahamburglar wrote: Are any of those facts wrong, Paul? Because the entire rest of my theory falls into place VERY logically from there. Nope.

Because from there you and JEK take this ridiculous leap in logic and create, out of whole cloth, this immortal wereolf spark lore that has no basis in what we've seen on the show.

You go from

If A then B

to

If B then XYZ

That's not logic. It's fantasy.

It is interesting to me that we have this same discussion every season and it's always the same people. Some of the people who were once part of the conversation have left others stayed and learned to modify their style to avoid making just logic leaps and stopped pushing their fantasies as statements of fact. Somme people, apparently, just don't learn.