Board Thread:False Info and Speculative Discussion/@comment-4723271-20161207204553/@comment-4723271-20161227022749

Obviously, there were problems, for one, Stiles wasn't too happy with how Scott was handling things but that had nothing to do with Theo taking down the pack. He took stopped them bc each and every one of them trusted him. He was smarter and he was able to manipulate them.

You're down playing Theo's accomplishments. Regardless of what was going on personally, that has never interfered with the pack before, not to mention they've been in much worse positions pack-wise. S1 for example, they were just a group of random human kids, with no real leader, Scott didn't know what the hell he was doing, and he was the only one with any powers, yet they still managed to defeat Peter. So that in-fighting excuse goes right out the window. It doesn't work considering what they've had to go through in the past

While it has been agreed upon that the S4 final was BS win for Scott, it still doesn't change the events that led to it. Peter did very little until that final fight. He also didn't bring the fight to Scott, man -to-man. Peter never intended to fight Scott, he brought the pack to Scott, hoping they'd kill him, and Peter would then come in and pick up the scraps, which is exactly what you accused Theo of doing. The only difference between the pack vs Berserker Scott (S4 finale) and Liam vs Scott (S5A finale) is that Theo actually succeeded in killing him.

There it goes again, underestimating Theo, you know.... that's what got Scott killed xD. He was always thinking ahead of them. While I think it's debatable that Peter may be more of a threat than Theo, I would never go as far as to say that Theo is nowhere near the threat that Peter was. S5 would say differently, Theo succeeded where Peter couldn't. He killed Scott, Peter failed at doing this multiple times. No matter how you look at it, no matter the variables and contributing factors, Theo's planning lead to Scott's death, something Peter couldn't do.

Well, you got me there, I can't argue with the facts, the smarter plan would've been going after Scott with Belasko's talons. He was too power hungry and screwed himself over bc of it. It was stupid, no other way to put that.