Board Thread:False Info and Speculative Discussion/@comment-67.162.31.47-20140715100605/@comment-4723271-20140716162408

50.198.8.217 wrote: There's a theory going around that it is Matt from season 2. He was obsessed with Allison and maybe he never actually died. It's a stretch, but it also explains why Kate, Peter, and Malia aren't on the list because at that time they were all thought to be dead. Honestly, I would be annoyed if it was Matt (no more people coming back from the dead!) but it would be unexpected. I guess its possible for the Benefactor to be matt, since he was becoming a kanima when Gerard drowned him maybe the process of becoming a kanima was far enough along to save him BUT I think it's unlikely