Board Thread:False Info and Speculative Discussion/@comment-24732895-20160411234226/@comment-26879545-20160511233445

Wri-El wrote: Yes. We're watching the same show, its only that we see things from different perspectives. Doesn't take a genius to see that. You... don't have a grasp on sarcasm via text, do you? This is a rhetorical question; it does not need an answer and is also sarcastic (just FYI).


 * "Has for what I said about Scott possibility to lose his True Alpha power and become just a Alpha if he killed with the intention to steal someone else's power, wasn't something I just dreamt about."

There's no difference between the powers of a regular Alpha or a True Alpha. The only difference is how their powers are able to be acquired and passed on. Scott is already an Alpha. He didn't kill another Alpha to gain that power. Now that he's an Alpha, he could, theoretically, kill with no consequences to his Alpha power. There's no evidence to support or disprove this theory because the show has given us little to no information about a True Alpha's restrictions after they become an Alpha.


 * "If you remember, Deucalion main goal was for Scott to join his pack but he wanted Scott to do so by killing. Which later another character, Deaton or Breaden if I'm not mistaken, said that Deucalion wanted Scott to kill so Scott could never achieve his true potential. So if killing would have stop Scott from becoming a True Alpha, then it isn't so far fetched to arrive at the logical conclusion that if Scott were to kill not to protect or defend someone but with the intent on stealing the power of another werewolf, that could (emphasis on COULD) make him lose his True Alpha status and he would become just a regular Alpha."

It wasn't Braeden or Deaton, it was Morrell, Deaton's sister that told him these things. She also said he intended to have Scott kill so he could never become a True Alpha. The rule of True Alphas, as established by Morrell, is that if a potential True Alpha were to kill, without attaining Alpha status, they would be unable to "will" themselves to Alphaship. They'd have to obtain that spark the "regular" way; by killing an Alpha.

What you're suggesting is farfetched because Scott's already attained his Alpha powers. There is no information that suggests that he will lose the "True Alpha" perks via killing after he's attained Alphaship.


 * "After all if Liam and Hayden are by Deaton words free to steal Scott power, while other werewolfs are not, then it stands to reason that if Scott for example went insane or lost control and killed Liam or Hayden, or any other werewolf, with the single purpose of stealing the power, it would have its price. After all Scott would've done something that seemingly goes against what a True Alpha has to be. A True Alpha, apparently has to grow on his own. No stealing."

How, exactly, are you reaching these conclusions? Liam and Hayden can steal his Alpha spark because they were directly turned by him. They are betas of his own making. Deaton established, in canon, that only a beta of his (Scott's) making can take his power. Any other beta could join Scott's pack and try to kill him, but they won't be able to steal Scott's spark because they aren't a beta of Scott's making. Hell, even Peter, Scott's old Alpha, stated he couldn't steal Scott's power. Peter even tried to tell Scott that the only way to get rid of his enemies for good (in this case, Peter himself) is to kill them, or else they'd keep coming back.

If Scott were to go "dark side" and kill someone, we don't know if there would be any consequences because canon hasn't established the rules reguarding this yet. A True Alpha can't kill, full stop, before they become an Alpha. That is what the current "rule" is. There are no rules established about killing after they become an Alpha. It's that simple. Stating that Scott will lose his "True Alpha" powers as a fact is wrong because canon hasn't established anything regarding it at this point in time.

We're literally having this argument on two different threads. For the sake of this thread topic, I'm not going to respond to this conversation on this thread.