Board Thread:False Info and Speculative Discussion/@comment-207.254.224.12-20140717193212/@comment-4091815-20140719173312

I've compared both on their first full moon with their betas since that is what prompted this conversation.

Derek was knocked down by Erica - I'm not counting the two on one action when Boyd joined in - and after Isaac took on Boyd, Derek was slashed and injured by Erica.

Scott was knocked down by Liam but never got slashed. He was able to hold Liam until Argent stepped in.

The outcomes were the same - Derek subdued Erica without harming her/Scott subdued Liam without harming him.

You could take it one step further and say Scott's feat was a bit more impressive since he was able to TALK Liam down while Derek had to head but Erica.

You could also take into account that Derek had the advantage of a confined space while Scott had to chase a fleeing Liam - but the outcomes were the same.